Kousatsu Note / Attack on Titan / Mysteries
Attack on Titan Foreshadowing: Every Setup That Paid Off, the Mysteries Left Open and What Chapter 1's Title Means
The most famous setup in Attack on Titan is the title of chapter 1, "To You, in 2,000 Years." It pays off in chapter 122, "From You, 2,000 Years Ago," which reveals it was about Ymir and Eren. Eren's dream in chapter 1, Mikasa's headaches, the Titans inside the walls and many other throwaway moments from early on come to mean something near the end. Some mysteries, like what the glowing creature at the origin of the Titans' power really is, were never fully answered.
This article covers Attack on Titan up to its final chapter.
What’s the most famous setup?
The title of chapter 1: “To You, in 2,000 Years.”
When the series began, no one knew what it meant. The answer came about eleven years later, in chapter 122, titled “From You, 2,000 Years Ago.”
Chapter 122 is the story of Ymir, the girl at the origin of the Titans’ power. From Ymir 2,000 years ago, to Eren 2,000 years later. The first chapter’s title had named the relationship at the very end of the story from the start.
Which setups paid off?
| Setup | Planted | Paid off | What it turned out to be |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chapter 1’s title, “To You, in 2,000 Years” | Chapter 1 | Chapter 122, “From You, 2,000 Years Ago” | It was about Ymir and Eren |
| Eren waking up in tears from a long dream | Chapter 1 | Near the end | He had been seeing memories of the future |
| Mikasa’s headaches | Many times from early on | Near the end | Tied to Ymir watching Mikasa from the Paths |
| Mikasa seeing Eren off | Chapter 1 | Near the end | It echoes the story’s last scene |
| The basement key | Chapter 1 | Around chapter 85 | Grisha’s journals reveal the truth about the world outside |
| A Titan buried in the wall | End of the fight with the Female Titan (the last episode of Season 1 in the anime) | The Rumbling | The walls themselves were made of hundreds of thousands of Colossal Titans |
| Reiner and Bertoldt’s “hometown” | Early on | Around chapter 42 | Their home was outside the walls, in Marley |
| The talking Titan who says “Ymir” | Ilse’s notebook (side story) | Middle of the story | Leads to the reveal that Titans were human, Subjects of Ymir |
| The Titan that ate Eren’s mother | Chapter 1 | Near the end | It was Dina, Grisha’s first wife. Eren himself was involved in where she went |
Many things from early on came together in the last few dozen chapters. Reread it, and you’re amazed at how much was already decided by volume 1.
Which mysteries are still unclear?
| Mystery | First appears | What the story shows |
|---|---|---|
| The glowing creature at the origin of the Titans’ power | Chapter 122 | Ymir meets it at the roots of the great tree, and it appears again near the end. What it is is never explained |
| Why Ymir loved the king | Chapter 122 to the final chapter | She served him even as a slave. What she felt is never fully put into words |
| How much of Eren’s actions were his own will | Near the end | Bound by memories of the future, or his own choice? Eren himself doesn’t give a clear answer |
| What became of the island and the world | Extra pages in volume 34 | The island is eventually burned in a war. The world after that isn’t shown |
The biggest is the glowing creature. It’s the very source of the Titans’ power, yet the story ends without giving it a name or a purpose. Personally, I think this is less a case of “not answering” than “choosing not to answer.” The story was about how humans used the power, not where it came from.
How many rereads does it take?
Read it a second time and it becomes a different story.
The first time, it’s a story about chasing mysteries. The second time, knowing what Eren knew, it’s a story about every word he says. Eren’s tears early on, and the way he treats Mikasa, mean something completely different once you’ve read to the end.
What the ending means is in the ending article, and Ymir is covered in the Ymir article.