Kousatsu Note / Attack on Titan / Titans and the world
Why Do Titans Eat People in Attack on Titan? Titans Are Human, Why They Can't Digest, and the Urge to Become Human Again
The Titans of Attack on Titan (the Pure Titans) were originally human beings: Eldians. Titans have no digestive system; the people they eat collect inside them and are vomited up when they are full. So they are not eating for nourishment. What the story does confirm is a mechanism: when a Pure Titan eats a human who holds one of the Nine Titans, it inherits that power and turns back into a human. The most convincing reading is that Titans attack people because the instinct to become human again is aimed at anyone at all. The power of the Titans itself began when Ymir's daughters ate her body to inherit it, and from the first page to the last, eating is tied to inheriting power.
This article contains spoilers close to the ending of Attack on Titan.
Do Titans really eat people?
They eat them. But they can’t digest them.
A Titan’s body has no stomach or intestines. The people it eats pile up inside, and when it is full, it throws them up in a mass. The story shows the remains of exactly that.
Titans don’t die if they don’t eat. As long as there is sunlight, they keep moving. They are not eating to survive. That is where this mystery starts.
What were the Titans, really?
Humans. More precisely, Eldians.
The Pure Titans roaming outside the walls were once ordinary people. Midway through the story it becomes explicit: an Eldian injected with Titan spinal fluid turns into a Titan in a flash of light.
Marley had been turning rebellious Eldians into Titans and releasing them on Paradis. The Titans outside the walls were those people. Even the Titan that ate Eren’s mother had once been a woman.
So why do they attack people?
From here on, this is interpretation.
The story confirms one important mechanism: when a Pure Titan eats a human who holds one of the Nine Titans, it inherits that power and becomes human again.
Ymir of the 104th had wandered as a Pure Titan for about 60 years. One day she ate Marcel, a Marleyan Warrior, gained the Jaw Titan, and turned back into a human. Armin, too, was turned into a Titan, ate Bertholdt, inherited the Colossal Titan, and became human again.
Personally, I read the Titans’ attacks as the instinct to become human again, aimed at anyone at all. A Titan can’t tell which human holds one of the Nine Titans. So it puts every human in front of it in its mouth. Almost everyone is a miss, so nothing happens, and they are simply thrown back up.
A creature with no reason to eat, eating people as if it were searching for something. Seen that way, the eeriness of the early Titans takes on a different shape.
Why do they only go after humans?
Titans pay no attention to animals. They walk right past cattle and horses and head straight for people.
The same instinct explains this. Only humans can hold the power of the Titans, so eating an animal would be pointless. Once we learned the Titans were human, this oddity had its answer too.
Why do people turn into Titans at all?
It all goes back to Ymir Fritz, about 2,000 years ago.
Ymir encountered a being sometimes called the Devil of All Earth and gained the power to become a Titan. After she died, that power was split into nine and passed down. Every Eldian carries Ymir’s blood, which is why spinal fluid turns them into Titans.
There’s more in Who Is Ymir Fritz?.
Why does “eating” matter so much?
Whenever the power of the Titans is passed on, eating comes with it.
When Ymir died, the king had his daughters eat her remains so her power would not be lost. When one of the Nine Titans passes to a new holder, the successor eats the previous one. Eren inherited the Attack Titan from his father Grisha by becoming a Titan and eating him.
In this story, eating means inheriting power and memory. And at the same time it means taking on the sins and suffering of the generation before. I think the revulsion of a Titan eating a person was, all along, the weight of inheritance made visible.
What happened to the Titans in the end?
When Eren fell, the power of the Titans vanished from the world. People who had been Titans became human again, and Eldians no longer turn into Titans. The meaning of the ending is covered in What the Attack on Titan Ending Means.
What we still don’t know
No character ever explains in one line why Titans eat people. “The instinct to become human again” is a strong reading, but it is not written as the answer. What the being Ymir met actually was is also never revealed.