Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / People
Who Is Alexander in Elden Ring? What Is Inside the Warrior Jar, and His Last Words, "A Warrior to His Last"
Alexander is a "warrior jar" who walks and fights on his own. Inside the jar are the corpses of warriors. Packing in the bodies of strong warriors makes the jar stronger, and carries those warriors on. His remains say the jars contain "dregs inherited from those who came before. Thus are warriors passed from jar to jar, carrying dreams of greatness." Inside Alexander, too, were the remains of a red-haired champion. A jar that inherited a hero's dream and aimed ever higher, at the last he challenges the protagonist, whom he has come to see as a champion, and breaks laughing, "the great Alexander lived as a warrior to his last!"
Who is Alexander?
He is a big jar stuck fast in a hole in the ground in Limgrave:
Oh my stars I’m so happy to see you! I am Alexander, also known as the Iron Fist. And as you can see, I’m stuck here. Please, can you help me out of this?
—— Alexander, Warrior Jar
And he asks:
Just give me a good smack from the rear, with something nice and big. And I’ll pop clean out. I’m sure! Don’t dally. No no, there’s no need to fret, I’m very well trained.
—— Alexander, Warrior Jar
Cheerful, straightforward, a little hapless. One of the most beloved characters in Elden Ring.
What was Alexander aiming for?
Alexander was on a journey to temper himself as a warrior:
I journey to the east, where I intend to further my education in the ways of war. Beyond these lands lie the scarlet rot-blighted Caelid Wilds. And upon their southern edge is Redmane Castle, in which a festival of combat is being held. Doesn’t the notion set your breast aflutter!
—— Alexander, Warrior Jar
What he was heading for was the “Radahn Festival”, where challengers face Radahn, the mightiest demigod of the Shattering. More on the festival in Who Is Radahn?
He explains why he quests:
I was created to be a warrior vessel. Many great warriors reside within me, ever dreaming of becoming a great champion. It’s my destiny. And the reason for which I quest.
—— Alexander, Warrior Jar
What is the jar’s “innards”?
This is the heart of every Alexander theory.
Cracked at the Radahn Festival, Alexander says afterwards:
…But don’t you think I’ve given up just yet. As luck would have it, there’s a veritable mountain of warriors’ bodies right here. If I can just squeeze this bunch down inside me, I’ll be a mighty warrior again in no time. And you know… The bodies found here are exceedingly fine. Who could expect any less from the very warriors who fought in the Shattering, the greatest of all wars!
—— Alexander, Warrior Jar
If I can just squeeze this bunch down inside me, I’ll be a mighty warrior again.
What fills a warrior jar is the corpses of warriors. The stronger the warriors packed inside, the stronger the jar. Alexander spoke to the corpses like this:
Alright lads, I’m going to take you on a little journey. You’ll all be inside me, and be part of me. From now on, we’re all in it together. So let’s all of us dream big.
—— Alexander, Warrior Jar
So let’s all of us dream big. The jar does not simply take in corpses. It goes on dreaming the dead warriors’ dream, together with them.
The keepsake you get for defeating Alexander says:
A keepsake of the warrior jar Alexander. Found at the core of the dead flesh that once filled the great jar. The jars contain dregs inherited from those who came before. Thus are warriors passed from jar to jar, carrying dreams of greatness.
—— Alexander’s Innards
Thus are warriors passed from jar to jar, carrying dreams of greatness.
A dead warrior becomes the innards of a jar, and when that jar breaks, the innards of a new jar. That is how a warrior’s dream is handed on. A warrior jar was a vessel that joins the dreams of the dead.
Who was inside Alexander?
Alexander’s shard says something worth noticing:
Shard of the late Alexander, a shattered warrior jar. Scraps of stewed flesh cling to the shard, and tatters of ornaments can be seen mingled within the slime. Relics of a red-haired champion, it would seem.
—— Shard of Alexander
Relics of a red-haired champion, it would seem.
After the Radahn Festival, Alexander gathered warriors’ bodies on the battlefield of Redmane Castle. And the one who fell at the Radahn Festival was the red-haired general, Radahn. Red hair was the “emblem of heroism” passed down from Radagon to Radahn.
For us, inside Alexander were remnants of Radahn, or of the Redmane Knights who fought beside him. A jar that admired heroes may truly have inherited a piece of one. But who the “red-haired champion” is, the description does not say.
Other warrior jars’ shards, by the way, say “Relics of ancient royal warriors, perhaps.” Each warrior jar holds different heroes.
Why did he challenge the protagonist at the end?
At the end of the story, in Crumbling Farum Azula, Alexander makes a request:
But that aside, I can’t believe you felled that giant. It was practically a god… Which means, I’ve but one thing to ask of you. Would you kindly undertake my ordeal? Come and tell me when you’re ready. I’ve been longing to fight a warrior as accomplished as you.
—— Alexander, Warrior Jar
I am the great jar warrior, Iron Fist Alexander! Lend me strength, O warriors within!
—— Alexander, Warrior Jar
Lend me strength, O warriors within! Alexander takes on his final ordeal together with the warriors sleeping inside him.
And after his defeat, he says:
My thanks. I knew you were the stuff of champions. It was a marvellous battle. I implore you, take what I bequeath…from inside me… All vessels are destined to one day break. But the great Alexander lived as a warrior to his last! Ha ha ha ha!
—— Alexander, Warrior Jar
Take what I bequeath, from inside me.
To the protagonist he recognized as a champion, he entrusts his innards, the dreams of the warriors he had carried. “Warriors are passed from jar to jar.” At the last, Alexander handed the dream on to a “new vessel”, the protagonist. The jar breaks, but the inheritance goes on. That, we think, is why he could laugh to the end.
What the Japanese text says
This site reads the game in the original Japanese. The jar’s creed is stated a little differently there.
- “Thus are warriors passed from jar to jar, carrying dreams of greatness.” The Japanese is 「戦士は壺に、そしてまた新たな壺に/そしていつか高みへと」: the warrior into a jar, and again into a new jar, and one day, to the heights. The Japanese has an end point, 高み (“the heights”): the inheritance is not endless, it is climbing toward something.
- “The jars contain dregs inherited from those who came before.” 「壺の中身は、継承の澱である」: a jar’s innards are the sediment of inheritance. 澱 is sediment, what settles at the bottom over time.
- “So let’s all of us dream big.” The Japanese is 「そして、共に見ようではないか/英雄たる夢を」: and let us see it together, the dream of being heroes. The English “dream big” is cheerful; the Japanese names the dream exactly.
- “But the great Alexander lived as a warrior to his last!” 「このアレキサンダーは、最後まで戦士の壺であったぞ!」: this Alexander was a warrior jar to the very end! Not “a warrior”, but “a warrior jar”. He is proud of being a jar.
What we still do not know
When, and by whom, warrior jars were made is not written.
Whether the “red-haired champion” really is Radahn is not clear either. Red hair fits Radahn’s knights, and his father Radagon too.
And how did Alexander reach Farum Azula? How a walking jar got to a city floating in the sky remains a small mystery.