Kousatsu Note / Fullmetal Alchemist / Mysteries
How Does Fullmetal Alchemist End? Why Ed Gave Up Alchemy and What Happened to Everyone
In the manga and Brotherhood, after Father is defeated, Ed gives up his own Gate of Truth, his very ability to use alchemy, to bring Al's body back. Before that, Al had traded his soul to restore Ed's right arm, so Ed wins his brother back by giving up alchemy. After the battle Hohenheim dies quietly at his wife Trisha's grave, and Marcoh offers to restore Mustang's sight. The brothers part ways, Al heading east to Xing and Ed heading west, and years later Ed marries Winry and they have two children.
This article spoils the entire ending of the manga and Brotherhood. The 2003 anime ends differently.
How does Fullmetal Alchemist end?
Ed gives up alchemy to get Al’s body back.
On the Promised Day, Ed and Al defeat Father. But that isn’t enough. Al’s real body is still trapped beyond the Gate of Truth.
So Ed performs one last transmutation. What he offers is his own Gate of Truth, in other words his ability to use alchemy at all. Ed can never use alchemy again, but Al comes back whole, soul and body together.
What did Al do before that?
During the battle, Ed’s right arm was still automail, and Father had him cornered.
Al traded his own soul to bring back the flesh-and-blood right arm Ed had lost beyond the Gate. With that arm, Ed landed the final blow on Father.
Al gave himself up so his brother could win. Ed gave up alchemy to win his brother back. The ending is about each brother letting go of the most important thing he had for the other.
Why could he give up alchemy?
Alchemy was part of who Ed was. He’d studied it since he was little, made his name as a State Alchemist, and used it to travel. Giving it up was no small decision.
From here on, this is inference. I think Ed could let it go so easily because the journey taught him he had friends even without alchemy. At the start, the brothers saw Equivalent Exchange as a cold law: to gain something, you lose something. The Ed at the end turns it into his own choice: for what matters, it’s all right to give.
Personally, I think this is the series’ answer. The journey to get their bodies back was also a journey to find what they wouldn’t regret giving up.
What happened to everyone after the battle?
Hohenheim dies quietly at his wife Trisha’s grave once the fighting is over. After centuries of life, he finally went home to his family.
Mustang lost his sight when he was forced into human transmutation on the Promised Day. Afterwards, the doctor Marcoh offers to heal his eyes with a Philosopher’s Stone, in exchange for letting the Ishvalans return to their homeland.
Ling goes back to Xing with a Philosopher’s Stone and becomes the new emperor, keeping his promise to unite the country’s many clans.
Officially, the whole thing was written off as an incident where the military’s top brass went rogue.
Why did the brothers go east and west?
Back in their own bodies, the brothers return to their hometown of Resembool. To honour everyone who was sacrificed, they decide to search for new forms of alchemy.
Al goes east to Xing to learn alkahestry, the alchemy that developed there. Ed goes west. He can’t use alchemy anymore, but he keeps studying it.
After travelling together all this time, the brothers choose separate roads for the first time. That also means neither has to live just to restore the other’s body anymore.
A scene years later shows Ed and Winry married with two children.
What we still don’t know
What the brothers found on their separate journeys, and what form the new alchemy took, isn’t shown. What lies beyond the Gate of Truth, and what “Truth” really is, also stays unexplained.