Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring Nightreign / People

Is the Recluse the Mastermind in Nightreign? The Shadow-Gnawing Infant Sought by a "Witch of the Deep Woods", and Its Tie to the Nightlord

Updated: 2026-10-25
Under a swirling purple night sky, a witch with a pointed hat and long white hair looks down from a cliff at a crumbling castle
A witch looking down on a land being swallowed by the Night Image: ELDEN RING NIGHTREIGN official website ©Bandai Namco Entertainment Inc. / ©2025 FromSoftware, Inc.
The short answer Strong inference

The Recluse is one of the "witches of the deep woods", who live far from people in the depths of the forest. She came to Limveld to search for a "beloved infant" she had birthed. That infant was a magical creature that devours shadows of any kind. In a great clash of armies, the infant devoured the enemy's shadows, lost itself, and bared its fangs at the witches too. The Recluse did not take the frightened infant in her arms, and lost her old friend, the Witch of the Wheel. Afterwards, the infant gnawed the Nightlord's shadow and became tied to the Nightlord. The Witch of the Wheel, hiding in the Roundtable Hold, says she was revived by the Nightlord's mercy, and asks the Recluse whether she would kill her own child. The Recluse is not the mastermind who created the Nightlord. But she was the "mother" of a child that became tied to it. Her story, we think, is one of atonement, a chance to redo what she could not do that day.

Who is the Recluse?

The Recluse is one of the Nightfarers, skilled in both sorceries and incantations. She looks like a witch, with a pointed hat and long white hair. Her journal begins:

Though my fellows call me by the name of “Recluse”, mine origin is as one of many — a witch of the deep woods. From mine seclusion amongst the trees, cause did I have to journey forth, to Limveld. For I had mind to search — for a certain something, coiled in shadow.

—— Recluse’s journal (Chapter 1)

For I had mind to search — for a certain something, coiled in shadow.

While the other Nightfarers fight to slay the Nightlord, the Recluse had a different purpose.

Her staff tells that she is a witch who came from outside the Lands Between:

A staff bound in red-drenched laurels that curses foes. Serves as a catalyst for sorceries. The laurels, imbued with a blood rite, unlock the peculiar fields of magic that flow through a given region. In the Lands Between, the staff invokes the strength of glintstones.

—— Recluse’s Staff

What was the “beloved infant” she was looking for?

This is the heart of every Recluse theory.

I search for, yes, my “beloved infant.” (snip) The Beloved Infant: The being that I, as a witch, birthed. It was never a true name bequeathed, though with a certain mirth we spoke of it as “the gnawling.”

—— Recluse’s journal (Chapter 2)

What the Recluse was searching for was an “infant” she had birthed as a witch. It had no true name; they called it “the gnawling”. True to the name, the infant was a being that gnaws on anything.

The Iron Menial finds a story in an old record from a distant land. During a war between nations, a beast devoured soldier after soldier. No one saw it; it left mountains of corpses, and the soldiers who survived said that their shadows had been gnawed.

The Recluse’s infant was a magical creature that gnaws on shadows. And in a great war, that power ran wild.

What happened to the Witch of the Wheel?

The Recluse had an old friend: a fellow student of the same arts, and the infant’s nurse, the “Witch of the Wheel”:

The Demise of the Witch of the Wheel: During a great clash of armies, the Infant overran the enemy, devouring their shadows. It was then that it lost itself, and bared its fangs at us. With time I have come to understand. It was yet young, and afraid, and I did not think to take it in my arms. To offer comfort of any kind. The price I paid was the loss of an old friend. I still remember, clear as day, her remains — shorn of any shadow.

—— Recluse’s journal (Chapter 6)

It was yet young, and afraid, and I did not think to take it in my arms.

In the war, the infant lost itself and bared its fangs even at the witches who raised it. The Recluse did not hold the frightened infant, and it vanished. And the Witch of the Wheel died, her shadow gone. The Recluse’s search in Limveld was also atonement for that day.

How is the infant connected to the Nightlord?

From a “Night Shard” found in Limveld and a “Vestige of Night” that had found its way into the Roundtable Hold, the Recluse traces the infant’s path:

The Vestige of Night: Teeth marks found in the Night Shard, alongside the Vestige of Night found embedded in the Roundtable Hold. Both seem to radiate an ancient magic which I myself imbued. I am certain, after mine Infant disappeared itself that day, it must have had an audience with the Nightlord. It ravened as if its appetite knew no bound — it would devour shadows of any stripe. The Nightlord’s own shade surely seemed irresistible to it. What must have become of my creature, after it did feast…

—— Recluse’s journal (Chapter 5)

The Nightlord’s own shade surely seemed irresistible to it.

The infant that vanished met the Nightlord and gnawed its shadow. And so the infant became tied to the Nightlord. More on the Nightlord in Who Is the Nightlord?

What did the Witch of the Wheel, hiding in the Hold, say?

From the Vestige of Night, the Recluse senses another familiar magic: that of the Witch of the Wheel, who should be long dead. And she finds her hiding in the Roundtable Hold.

Asked how she knew, the Witch greets her old comrade. It is no wonder she is surprised, the Witch says: she died in war and was buried, and was brought back by the Nightlord’s mercy.

The Witch of the Wheel says that her shadow was eaten by the infant and she died, and that as part of the infant she still remains here. And she presses the Recluse to give up the foolish act of standing in the lord’s way, then puts it another way: would you kill your own child?

Defeating the Nightlord may mean killing the infant tied to it. And the Witch of the Wheel, revived as part of the infant, would vanish too. She asked the Recluse to abandon her duty as a Nightfarer.

Is the Recluse the mastermind?

“Is the Recluse the mastermind?” is a common question. But as far as her journal goes, the Recluse is not the mastermind who created the Nightlord.

The beginning of the Night was the knight Heolstor, whose country was destroyed and who cursed the world. The Recluse’s infant gnawed that Nightlord’s shadow and became tied to it. The Iron Menial, too, doubts that a mere magical creature could become something so great, and suspects it is not so simple.

Still, the Recluse is not free of responsibility. She birthed a shadow-eating infant, let it run wild in war, and let it escape without holding it. Once the infant became tied to the Nightlord, the Night may have grown deeper. For us, the most accurate thing to say is that the Recluse is not the mastermind, but the “mother” of a child that became tied to the Nightlord.

How does the Recluse’s story end?

After the confrontation with the Witch of the Wheel, the Iron Menial says that in a dream, the Nightlord handed him a “Bone-Like Stone”:

A disturbing stone with a distinct lifelessness. The bone of an outer god with the power to expunge divine essence, but that can also be destroyed by the same essence. The choice was left to the witch. As per the wishes of the one who bestowed it.

—— Bone-Like Stone

The choice was left to the witch. As per the wishes of the one who bestowed it.

A last clue entrusted to its mother, the Recluse, by the infant that is with the Nightlord. Touch the stone, and the infant’s voice can faintly be heard:

Bone-Like Stone: The Infant’s voice can be heard when softly touching the stone. Please, have patience. I shall come to thee, I swear.

—— Recluse’s journal (Chapter 7)

Defeat the Primordial Nightlord carrying this stone, and an infant’s crying is heard from deep in the Roundtable Hold. The Recluse at last picks up her infant. And the Witch of the Wheel gives her last words, thanking her comrade for loving their Night:

“I thank thee, for bestowing thy love upon our Night.” Thus did mine old companion speak to me in parting. The words resounded within, as I took the Infant in mine arms. As I did what I once could not, all those years ago. The crying hath now ceased. The gentle night within its breast knoweth now a peaceful slumber.

—— Recluse’s journal (Chapter 8)

As I did what I once could not, all those years ago.

That day, she could not hold her frightened infant. After defeating the Nightlord, the Recluse was at last able to redo it. For us, this is the most redemptive ending in Nightreign’s journals. Not by hating the Night, but by “loving” it, she could say goodbye to both her infant and her old friend.

What the Japanese text says

This site reads the game in the original Japanese. The Recluse’s voice is quite different there.

  • Her voice. The English Recluse writes in an archaic style (“mine origin”, “hath”, “thee”). The Japanese Recluse writes in plain, soft, slightly playful speech: 「影にまつわる、探しものをするつもり」, I mean to look for something to do with shadows. The English sounds like an ancient witch; the Japanese sounds like a gentle woman talking to herself.
  • “The gnawling.” The infant’s nickname is かじりやさん in Japanese: little Mr. Nibbler, a cosy, childish name with the honorific さん. It makes the infant sound more like a beloved pet than a monster.
  • “It was yet young, and afraid, and I did not think to take it in my arms.” 「今なら分かる。あの子はただ、怯えていたのだと/けれど私は、それを抱き止めてあげられなかった」: now I understand: that child was only frightened. But I could not hold it. The Japanese says she could not; the English says she did not think to.
  • “The gentle night within its breast knoweth now a peaceful slumber.” 「胸の内の柔らかな夜は、ただ静かに眠っている」: the soft night within the breast simply sleeps quietly. The Japanese does not say whose breast. It can be read as the infant’s, or as her own heart, so the night sleeps both in her arms and inside her.
  • “The Witch of the Wheel.” In Japanese, 輪の魔女, the Witch of the Ring (or Circle).

What we still do not know

Why the Recluse birthed a shadow-eating infant is not told.

Whether the Witch of the Wheel was truly on the Nightlord’s side, or only wanted to protect the infant, is not clear either.

And the “Nightlord” who gave the Bone-Like Stone to the Iron Menial: was it Heolstor, or the infant? That too is never revealed in the game.