Kousatsu Note / Dark Souls / Characters

GamesDark Souls Characters

Frampt or Kaathe: Which Serpent Is Right? The Primordial Serpents and What Each Wants in Dark Souls

Updated: 2026-10-31
The short answer Unresolved

Frampt and Kaathe are both great serpents known as primordial serpents. Kingseeker Frampt asks you to succeed Gwyn and link the fire. Darkstalker Kaathe reveals that Gwyn feared the dark and prolonged the Age of Fire, and asks you to become the Dark Lord. Neither seems to be lying, but each is trying to steer you toward the ending they want. The game never settles which one is right.

This article covers the ending of Dark Souls.

Who is Frampt?

A great serpent who appears after you ring the two bells.

Frampt calls himself Gwyn’s close friend and asks you to become Gwyn’s successor. To do that, you must obtain the Lordvessel in Anor Londo and fill it with Lord Souls: the souls of Gravelord Nito and the Witch of Izalith, and those of the Four Kings of New Londo and Seath the Scaleless, who were given shards of Gwyn’s Lord Soul.

Who is Kaathe?

The other primordial serpent.

Kaathe appears deep in the New Londo Ruins, at the bottom of the Abyss. And he tells a completely different story from Frampt. Gwyn feared the dark and linked the fire so the Age of Fire would never end. Humans are descended from the pygmy who found the Dark Soul, and an age of humans should have followed the Age of Fire. Kaathe asks you to become the Dark Lord.

How do their stories differ?

FramptKaathe
What he wants you to doLink the fireDon’t link it; become the Dark Lord
On GwynA great kingA king who feared the dark and prolonged the Age of Fire
On humansSays nothingDescendants of the pygmy who found the Dark Soul
Where he appearsFirelink ShrineThe Abyss beneath the New Londo Ruins

Which one is right?

From here on, this is speculation.

Kaathe’s story lines up with other clues in a lot of places. That humans were born from the dark matches the “furtive pygmy” in the opening. That Gwyn linked the fire is certain, since the final boss is Gwyn, Lord of Cinder.

But Kaathe isn’t necessarily acting out of goodwill either. He’s the one who once lured the Four Kings of New Londo into the Abyss and brought about New Londo’s ruin. I think it’s more natural to see both serpents as trying to lead you down the path they want.

The two endings are covered in the linking the fire article.

Personally, I think Frampt and Kaathe are alike in that both see you as a stand-in for someone else. To Frampt, you’re Gwyn’s successor. To Kaathe, you’re the Dark Lord. Who you are isn’t for the serpents to decide. It’s for you.