Kousatsu Note / Dark Souls / Endings
What Is Linking the Fire? The Age of Fire and Dark Lord Endings in Dark Souls, and Which Is Right
Linking the fire means someone with a powerful soul offers themselves as kindling to keep the fading First Flame burning. The first to do it was Gwyn, Lord of Sunlight. Dark Souls has two endings: Link the Fire, where you become the new Lord of Cinder and the Age of Fire continues, and Dark Lord, where you walk away without linking the fire and usher in the Age of Dark, the age of humans. The game never says which is right, but it does say that linking the fire only postpones the Age of Dark.
This article covers the ending of Dark Souls.
What is linking the fire?
Offering yourself to the fading flame.
The First Flame is what sustains the Age of Fire. As it weakens, so does the power of the gods, and darkness and the Undead curse spread across the world. The only way to stop it is for someone with a powerful soul to enter the Kiln of the First Flame and become kindling to keep the fire burning.
Who linked the fire first?
Gwyn, who began the Age of Fire, linked the fire with his own body when it started to fade. The final boss of Dark Souls is that same Gwyn, nearly burned out after linking the fire: Gwyn, Lord of Cinder.
What endings are there?
Two.
| Ending | What you do | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| Link the Fire | After defeating Gwyn, light the bonfire in the Kiln | You become the new Lord of Cinder, and the Age of Fire continues |
| Dark Lord | Leave the Kiln without lighting it | The fire goes out and the serpents kneel to you. The Age of Dark begins |
Is the Dark Lord ending the bad ending?
Not necessarily.
One of the serpents, Darkstalker Kaathe, tells you this: Gwyn feared the dark and linked the fire so the Age of Fire would never end. But what should come after the Age of Fire is the Age of Dark, the age of humans, because humans are descended from the pygmy who found the Dark Soul.
By Kaathe’s account, linking the fire only postpones the coming Age of Dark. Even the Undead curse starts to look like a mechanism for getting people to link the fire.
Which ending is right?
From here on, this is speculation.
The game never says which is right. But the sequel, Dark Souls III, shows a world where the fire has been linked again and again until it’s nearly burned out. Keeping the fire linked led to a flame that grows weaker no matter how many times it’s linked.
Personally, what I find interesting is less which ending is right and more that Dark Souls turns into a question of whether you believe a mission someone hands you. Do what the first serpent says, and you link the fire. Only those who doubt and dig into things themselves reach the Dark Lord ending. Whichever you choose, it’s the result of what you chose to believe.