Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / People
Who Is Blackguard Big Boggart in Elden Ring? The Prawn-Boiling Petty Thug, His Iron Ball, and Why He Feared the Dung Eater
Big Boggart is an iron-masked "blackguard" who boils prawns beside a shack in Liurnia of the Lakes. His weapon, the Iron Ball, is a spherical iron manifer, and its weighty blows shatter bones with ease. His iron mask is the kind forced on convicted prisoners. Boggart is the thief who stole Rya's necklace, and he calls himself a "petty thug". But the one man he feared above all was the Dung Eater. Long ago they were held in the same gaol, and Boggart stood rooted to the spot while his friend was defiled. Later, when Boggart himself is killed and defiled by the Dung Eater, he begs not to be cursed. Boggart, we think, is a very human petty thug, who in Japanese asks for only one thing at the end, to be born right next time.
Who is Big Boggart?
In southern Liurnia of the Lakes, by a shack at the water’s edge, a big man is boiling something in a pot. He wears a rusted iron mask:
What are you lookin’ at? You trying to start something, mate?
—— Blackguard Big Boggart
Foul-mouthed and quick to threaten to “crack you in ‘alf”, he is plainly a rough type. His name is Big Boggart. The descriptions call him a “blackguard”.
What is the “Iron Ball”?
Boggart’s weapon is an iron ball worn on the fist:
Iron manifer of spherical shape. Big Boggart the blackguard’s weapon of choice. Not a weapon to be taken lightly, as its weighty blows shatter bones with ease.
—— Iron Ball
Not a weapon to be taken lightly, as its weighty blows shatter bones with ease.
The owner of this much-searched weapon is Boggart. Not a sword, not an axe, but a round iron ball on the fist. It is not a refined weapon, but its blows shatter bones. A description that warns you not to take it lightly seems to describe Boggart himself: take him for a mere thug and you will get hurt.
And the iron mask Boggart wears is the kind forced on prisoners:
Iron mask forced on convicted prisoners. Worn by the blackguard Big Boggart. To Boggart, the mask made him all the more threatening, and helped him get what he wanted. But it was also a mirror of his emptiness.
—— Blackguard’s Iron Mask
Boggart was once a prisoner.
Who stole Rya’s necklace?
At the entrance to Liurnia of the Lakes, Rya the Scout asks the player for help: a blackguard has stolen her necklace.
Necklace stolen from Rya by the blackguard. Features a relief of a dignified looking woman from a foreign country. It appears to hold great significance for Rya.
—— Rya’s Necklace
That “blackguard” was Boggart. When the player brings up the necklace, Boggart says, without a shred of shame:
Oh, that necklace what you’re after, is it? Hmm, well… Show me what it’s worth to you, and I’ll consider parting ways with it. I’m not in love with it or nothing.
—— Blackguard Big Boggart
You what? Sod the particulars, mate. Ain’t my fault people are so bloody stupid, is it? Don’t like that it’s stolen? Don’t sodding buy it..
—— Blackguard Big Boggart
Ain’t my fault people are so bloody stupid, is it? A petty crook to the bone. More on Rya in Who Is Rya?
Why is he boiling prawns?
After the necklace deal, Boggart starts selling you freshly boiled prawns too:
Never met someone with a taste for prawn I couldn’t trust. We’d make good mates, I reckon. I’ll be seeing ya.
—— Blackguard Big Boggart
Never met someone with a taste for prawn I couldn’t trust. Not quite the line you expect from a thief. But Boggart’s boiled prawns do seem to have been rather good:
Boiled prawn meat. A prime specimen of plump and moist meat. True connoisseurs know how to keep from over-salting. Boosts physical damage negation for a certain duration. The meat actually looks to have come from a crayfish. Not that it matters, it’s delicious all the same.
—— Boiled Prawn
When you meet him again on the Altus Plateau, he is boiling crab:
Boiled crab meat. A prime specimen of plump and moist meat. True connoisseurs know how to keep from over-salting. Greatly boosts physical damage negation for a certain duration. Unlike the “prawn” sold, this truly is crab. Not that it matters, it’s delicious all the same.
—— Boiled Crab
“Actually a crayfish.” “This truly is crab.” Even the descriptions sound like they are having fun. A crook, but a good cook. Boggart is one of the few villains in Elden Ring you cannot quite hate.
What are his doubts about the Erdtree?
Once you are prawn-buying friends, Boggart lets a little of his real feelings slip:
You’re Tarnished too, ain’tcha? Can you see it then? The guidance of grace, I mean. I can’t see it at all no more. Makes no bloody sense anyway, why some no-name shithead like me should get called to the Lands Between. Cruel bloody joke, you ask me. Maybe something went tits up with it. Maybe… it’s been broke for a good long time. The Erdtree, I’m sayin’.
—— Blackguard Big Boggart
Makes no bloody sense anyway, why some no-name shithead like me should get called to the Lands Between.
Boggart, too, was a Tarnished who saw the guidance of grace and came back to the Lands Between. But he can no longer see it. And he suspects that the Erdtree, for calling back a petty crook like him, is the one that has gone wrong.
Why did he fear the Dung Eater?
This is the heart of every Boggart theory.
Boggart warns the player about a certain man:
Mate, there’s somethin’ I should probably tell ya. You ‘eard of the Dung Eater? E’s a madman, ‘as it out for everyone. Curses ‘em. Goes ‘round in this rank armour, an’ all. You see ‘im though, stay well away. I was in the same gaol as him, once, so I know first ‘and. E’s a god-forsaken monster. Not just some petty thug like me.
—— Blackguard Big Boggart
I was in the same gaol as him, once, so I know first ‘and.
Boggart was once in the same gaol as the Dung Eater. And he tells you what he saw there:
E’s a killer. Kills people and curses their souls… Does all sorts of shit to their corpses, to keep ‘em cursed, forever. I ain’t seen nothin’ more disgustin’ in all my years. I ain’t ever been more scared, neither. Rooted to the bloody spot… While ‘e did all that, to my friend…
—— Blackguard Big Boggart
I ain’t ever been more scared, neither. Rooted to the bloody spot… While ‘e did all that, to my friend…
A petty crook who cheats, steals, and threatens to crack you in half. That Boggart stood frozen, like a child, while his friend was defiled, and could do nothing. Before real terror, his thuggery was no use at all.
The Dung Eater is a man who grows the “Seedbed Curse” in the corpses he kills, so their souls cannot return to the Erdtree. More in Who Is the Dung Eater?
How does Boggart die?
When the player frees the Dung Eater from his gaol, Boggart realises the terrible man is out and about again:
Yeah…and now I seen it ‘ere, again. Never thought I would. What ‘e does to those bodies. It was… It was ‘im, no question. That monster. He’s lurkin’ round ‘ere.
—— Blackguard Big Boggart
And Boggart himself is killed and defiled by the Dung Eater. His spirit speaks to the player:
Heh…serves me right. Fitting bloody end, for a jumped up little shit with big ideas…
—— Blackguard Big Boggart
Help me out, would ya, mate… I don’t wanna get cursed. Just let me die… I don’t wanna live like this…not anymore… So, please…
—— Blackguard Big Boggart
I don’t wanna get cursed. Just let me die.
In the English, Boggart asks simply to die rather than live on cursed. In the Japanese, he asks for something more, and it is the line we find the most piercing of any petty villain in Elden Ring (see below).
Boggart knew his life had not been an honest one. The Dung Eater’s curse is something that keeps a soul from returning to the Erdtree. And from Boggart’s defiled corpse, the player obtains a “Seedbed Curse”. A petty crook’s last wish becomes material for the Dung Eater’s curse. It is a very cruel turn.
What the Japanese text says
This site reads the game in the original Japanese. Boggart’s last plea is quite different there.
- “I don’t wanna get cursed. Just let me die… I don’t wanna live like this…not anymore…” The Japanese is 「俺は、呪われたくない。死ぬのはいい、だけど/今度こそ、真っ当に産まれたいんだよ…」: I don’t want to be cursed. Dying is fine, but… this time, I want to be born right. In Japanese, Boggart is not asking to die. He accepts death, and asks to be reborn, decently, next time. Returning to the Erdtree and being born again was the one hope left to him, and the Dung Eater’s curse is exactly what takes rebirth away. The English loses this wish entirely.
- “Not just some petty thug like me.” 「あいつは、俺みたいな小悪党とは違う、恐ろしい男なんだ」. 小悪党, petty villain, is how Boggart sees himself throughout, and it returns in his line after death: 「勘違いした小悪党には、相応しい最後ってわけだ」 (a fitting end for a petty villain who got above himself).
- “Rooted to the bloody spot.” 「ただ怖くて、ガキみたいに竦みあがっちまってたよ」: I was just scared, frozen stiff like a kid.
- “Never met someone with a taste for prawn I couldn’t trust.” 「…エビ好きに、悪人はいねえ」: no one who likes prawns is a bad person. Funnier coming from a thief.
- “Ain’t my fault people are so bloody stupid.” 「いつだって、騙される奴が悪いんだ」: it’s always the fault of the one who gets fooled.
What we still do not know
What crime Boggart was imprisoned for is not told.
Who the “friend” in the Dung Eater’s gaol was, we do not know either.
And after Boggart is defiled, will he ever be reborn, as he wished in Japanese? No ending that lifts the Dung Eater’s curse is shown in the game.