Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / People
Who Is Sellen in Elden Ring? The "Graven Witch" Who Sought the Primeval Current, and Her Wish for "Fallen Children of the Stars"
Sellen was the most promising sorceress in the history of the Academy of Raya Lucaria. But she was expelled for trying to restore the "primeval current" of glintstone sorcery, rather than the sorcery of an Academy gone toothless under the Carian royal family. The official reason was suspicion that, as the "Graven Witch", she had done terrible things to many sorcerers. To Sellen, sorcery was the study of the stars and the life therein. "So that we, fallen children of the stars, might beam with brilliance once again." She would spare no sacrifice for that wish, and at the same time she was a teacher who truly cherished her apprentice. That she herself finally becomes a Graven Mass was, we think, where her inquiry had to end.
Who is Sellen?
She is the sorceress who teaches you glintstone sorcery, in the cellar of some ruins in Limgrave. When you first ask to become her apprentice, Sellen says:
Ahh, a yen for glintstone sorceries? Well, your aptitude does appear…passable. But one must choose one’s masters wisely. I was exiled from the Academy of Raya Lucaria, as a reviled, apostate witch. Do you still wish to learn from me?
—— Sorceress Sellen
Once you are her apprentice, she gives her lessons with a mix of strictness and delight. Her habit of calling you “my apprentice” is memorable.
Thops, a sorcerer from the Academy, remembers Sellen like this:
Sellen was well known. The most promising sorceress in the history of the academy. I followed her at school, but there may as well have been an ocean between us. But Sellen was expelled from the academy. Accused of unthinkable treatment of certain sorcerers, under the name of the Graven Witch.
—— Sorcerer Thops
The Graven Witch. The most promising sorceress in the Academy’s history had been expelled on suspicion of “unthinkable treatment of certain sorcerers”.
What was Sellen aiming for?
Sellen herself gives the reason for her exile:
If you recall, I was exiled from the Academy of Raya Lucaria. It was for attempting to restore the primeval current of glintstone sorcery. The toothless pedantry peddled by the Carian royal family can rot for all I care. I want glintstone sorceries that open our minds, unbound by terrestrial taboos. No matter what we give in return.
—— Sorceress Sellen
No matter what we give in return. Sellen believed the Academy’s sorcery had gone “toothless” once it accepted the Carian royal family. She was trying to bring back sorcery as it originally was, unbound by the royal family: the “primeval current”.
Then what is glintstone sorcery? Sellen teaches you in one of her lessons:
Our art draws upon the powers embedded in glintstone. But what is the nature of such power? Glintstone is the amber of the cosmos. Golden amber contains the remnants of ancient life, and houses its vitality, while glintstone contains residual life, and thus the vitality of the stars. It should not be forgotten, that glintstone sorcery is the study of the stars, and the life therein.
—— Sorceress Sellen
Glintstone is the amber of the cosmos. Glintstone holds the residue of the stars’ life. So sorcery is the study of the stars’ life. That was Sellen’s view.
What does “Graven Witch” mean?
This is the heart of every Sellen theory.
The sorcerers Sellen is accused of harming. In the Academy there are enemies that look like many sorcerers’ bodies fused into one mass: the Graven School and the Graven Mass. Her title, “Graven Witch”, is thought to come from these.
Why fuse sorcerers into a mass? The clue is Sellen’s final goal. Sellen wished to bring the bodies of the primeval sorcerers Azur and Lusat to the Academy:
Master Lusat is another founding glintstone sorcerer. I need him to restore the primeval current of glintstone sorcery. He’s nigh a child of the stars, such is his body now…
—— Sorceress Sellen
And her words when that goal is achieved:
With the bodies of Masters Azur and Lusat returned, the academy can hone the primeval current. So that we, fallen children of the stars, shall beam with brilliance once again.
—— Sorceress Sellen
So that we, fallen children of the stars, shall beam with brilliance once again.
Sellen thought of humans as “fallen children”, children fallen from the stars. And if sorcery were mastered, people could become children of the stars once more. To that end, she sought the bodies of the masters who had come closest to the stars, and gathered sorcerers’ bodies into one. For us, the “mass” was an experiment to come closer to the stars.
What is a primal glintstone?
When Sellen realizes her body will not last much longer, she entrusts you with her “primal glintstone”:
Glintstone from within the sorceress Sellen’s body. Seemingly half-alive, blood vessels are visible within. In essence, a primal glintstone is a sorcerer’s soul. If transplanted into a compatible new body after their original body dies, the sorcerer will rise again. “My apprentice, do you think it distasteful?”
—— Sellen’s Primal Glintstone
A primal glintstone is a sorcerer’s soul. A sorcerer’s soul lives in the glintstone, and moving it into a new body brings them back. Sellen treated the body as a vessel. Perhaps that is why gathering other people’s bodies gave her no pause.
Move this primal glintstone into a new body, and Sellen comes back. That body is one of the “puppets” Preceptor Seluvis kept hidden. More on Seluvis in Who Is Seluvis?
Jerren or Sellen, whose side do you take?
Before the revived Sellen appears Witch-Hunter Jerren, come to strike her down as an enemy of Caria.
The protagonist must choose a side.
Side with Jerren, and Sellen is slain. Her last words:
Ahh, how can this be… …every fallen child… must shine again…
—— Sorceress Sellen
Side with Sellen, and she defeats Jerren and returns to the Academy. Rennala, Queen of Caria, is no more. The day to restore the primeval current has come, she rejoices:
Do you see this? The Queen of Caria is no more. My apprentice. Will you stay with us, here at the academy? Oh, I know it’s not possible. You have your own calling. To be the next Elden Lord. But do think of me. Of your teacher. On the eve of your crowning. You will always be my darling pupil.
—— Sorceress Sellen
You will always be my darling pupil. The teacher who once wondered aloud whether she had been strict enough finally says this.
Why does Sellen become a Graven Mass in the end?

After you side with Sellen and she returns to the Academy, visit the Grand Library once more, and Sellen has changed beyond recognition. She has become a “Graven Mass”, sorcerers’ bodies fused together:
U…urgh M-my…apprentice…
—— Sorceress Sellen
Even as a mass, Sellen calls you “my apprentice”.
Why did Sellen become a mass? The text gives no reason. But connect what we have seen, and something comes into view. Sellen was called the “Graven Witch”, and made sorcerers into masses. And to come closer to the stars, she brought in the masters’ bodies to perfect the primeval current.
For us, Sellen made herself into a mass. As the final step to perfect the primeval current at the Academy and approach the stars, she joined herself to the masters and the sorcerers. What she had done to others, at the last she did to herself. That, we think, is where Sellen’s inquiry had to end.
Even so, to the player it simply looks sad. The teacher who called you her darling pupil has become a mass that can barely speak. Sellen showed, with her own body, how dangerous the pursuit of the primeval current was.
What the Japanese text says
This site reads the game in the original Japanese. The key names and lines about Sellen are blunter there.
- “Graven Witch.” Her Japanese title is 塊の魔女 (katamari no majo): the witch of masses, or of lumps. The English “graven” means carved or engraved. The Japanese 塊 simply means a clump, a mass of things stuck together. It points directly at the fused bodies of the Graven Mass enemies, whose Japanese name uses the same word.
- “Unthinkable treatment of certain sorcerers.” Thops’s Japanese is 「数多の魔術師を惨たらしく手にかけた疑いで」: on suspicion of cruelly killing many sorcerers. The English is vague about both how many and what was done. The Japanese says many, and killed.
- Her dying words. “…every fallen child… must shine again…” is, in Japanese, 「…ああ、なぜだ…/なぜ、落とし子は…輝ける星に…」: ah, why… why, the fallen children… into shining stars… The Japanese is an unfinished question, why, not a statement that they must. She dies asking why her wish could not come true.
- “Fallen children of the stars.” Sellen’s word is 落とし子 (otoshigo): literally a dropped child, also used of a noble’s illegitimate child. It is the same word used for Astel, “the offspring of darkness”, and for the pests of the scarlet rot. In Japanese, humans, Astel, and the pests are all “dropped children” of something greater.
What we still do not know
Whether Sellen really harmed many sorcerers remains, in Thops’s words, only an accusation. Sellen herself neither denies nor admits it.
Whether Sellen became a mass of her own will, as a side effect of the primeval current, or by someone else’s hand, is unknown too.
And what is a “child of the stars”? What would it mean for humans, as fallen children, to become children of the stars again? This is one of Elden Ring’s great mysteries, tied to Ranni’s “age of the stars” and to Astel. More in What Was Ranni’s Goal? and What Is Astel?