Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / People
Who Is Seluvis in Elden Ring? Why He Dies, His Link to Pidia, and the Puppet Scheme, Explained
We think Seluvis was a puppet controlled by the servant Pidia. As he dies, Pidia calls those attacking him "my puppets", and at the same moment Seluvis goes still in the same pose as a puppet. Seluvis died because, at the end of his scheme to make Ranni a puppet, the puppeteer Pidia was killed by his own puppets. Who made them do it is never written, but Ranni is the natural reading.
Who is Seluvis?
He is a preceptor of sorcery who lives in a tower near Ranni’s Rise in Liurnia of the Lakes. He serves Ranni, and he is the first person you meet when you enter her service.
I see… You must be Ranni’s new hireling. Yes, yes, I’ve heard all about you. I am Seluvis, preceptor in the sorcerous arts. I don’t know what it is the mistress sees in a provincial Tarnished like you, but since we have the misfortune of serving the same Lady, I ask that you kindly try not to drag us all down with you.
—— Preceptor Seluvis
He looks down on you from the very first meeting, calling you “provincial”. Most players sense he is up to something from the start.
And he was. In the end, he is found dead in his own tower, still kneeling.
What was Seluvis scheming?
The first thing Seluvis asks of you is to make a warrior named Nepheli drink a potion:
Perhaps I’ll give you something to do. I’d like you to find a woman called Nepheli, to administer a potion. Even you can do that much, can’t you?
—— Preceptor Seluvis
Whoever drinks this potion falls asleep and becomes Seluvis’s “puppet”. Seluvis was turning people into puppets and collecting them.
It’s no sin, pining for a puppet to cherish.
—— Preceptor Seluvis
The descriptions of his puppets set out his tastes directly:
One of Seluvis’s favorite puppets. Use to summon the spirit of Nepheli Loux. Puppet of a warrior who was betrayed by her pure heart. Wields a Stormhawk Axe in both hands and uses the Thunderstorm skill. A diamond in the rough, deserving of special care lest its potential be squandered. Nepheli Loux truly was a warrior.
The Dung Eater despaired at how he met his end. How hideous and sinister this puppet is, and yet, its utter despair invites one to care for it.
The beautiful and the hideous, the broken-hearted and the despairing, he “cherishes” them all alike. That was the kind of puppeteer Seluvis was.
Was his real target Ranni?
Yes. The final goal of Seluvis’s scheme was to make his own mistress, Ranni, a puppet:
Perhaps, you’d be interested in a little scheme of mine? It will produce the finest of puppets. Which I aspire to cherish with these very hands. A ploy to fool even Lady Ranni… How does that sound?
—— Preceptor Seluvis
What he needed for it was Amber Starlight:
If the stars command our fates, then amber-hued stars must command the fates of the gods. Such is the belief that inspired the use of these shards to prepare a most special draught.
A draught made from the fate of the gods could enslave even a demigod. So Seluvis believed:
With that, my special draught will gleam with nectar-sweetness. And even a demigod would be slave to its charms…
—— Preceptor Seluvis
The irony is that Ranni has already cast off her body and lives in a doll. He was trying to make a puppet of a doll.
If you try to give the draught to Ranni, she sees through everything:
Well, this is a most unpleasant awakening. The depths of wickedness never fail to surprise me. I am saddened. That thou wouldst succumb to such depravity. Led astray by Seluvis, with devious tonic in hand, Didst thou think to have thy way with me?
—— Ranni
Why did Seluvis die?
After you try to give the draught to Ranni, or after you hand Ranni the Fingerslayer Blade, either way, Seluvis is found dead in his tower. He is kneeling, in the same pose as the puppets he collected.
At the same time, someone else dies in the storeroom beneath the tower: Pidia, servant of the Carian royal family. As you approach the storeroom, you hear Pidia being attacked:
Argh! Aargh! S-stop, please, stop! Y-you’re my puppets! I loved you with all I have! How could you forget… such bliss?
—— Pidia, Carian Servant
“You’re my puppets!” Pidia’s attackers were puppets. And Pidia dies as their master.
Was Seluvis really Pidia?
This is the heart of every Seluvis theory.
It was supposed to be Seluvis who collected and cherished the puppets. Yet the one who screamed “my puppets” at his death was Pidia. And at the very moment Pidia dies, Seluvis goes still in the same pose as a puppet.
Pidia’s first words when he meets you are odd too:
O-oh! Y-you! I, er, sorry, your worship…
—— Pidia, Carian Servant
Pidia starts to address you as a plain “you”, then catches himself and switches to “your worship”. Talking down to you was Seluvis’s habit.
From all this comes the theory that Seluvis was a puppet controlled by Pidia, and the true puppeteer was Pidia.
For us, this theory fits best:
- Pidia calls his attackers “my puppets”
- Pidia and Seluvis die at the same moment
- Seluvis’s corpse is posed like a puppet
- At their first meeting, Pidia nearly addresses you the way Seluvis does
A puppeteer obsessed with “cherishing” puppets had a puppet of his own out in front. Read that way, even Seluvis’s unnatural arrogance starts to look like a role being played by the one pulling the strings.
According to the English wiki, Pidia’s lines are stored inside Seluvis’s lines in the game data, and the same voice actor plays both. Since that is not in-game evidence, we do not count it, but it does suggest what the developers intended.
Who had Pidia killed?
The text does not say. But both deaths come right after events involving Ranni: either after you try to give her the draught, or after you hand her the Fingerslayer Blade.
Ranni had seen through Seluvis’s scheme. And with the Fingerslayer Blade in hand, she had no further need of him. If anyone could turn the puppets against their master, it was Ranni the Witch.
A puppeteer killed by his own puppets. A cold judgement, and very much like Ranni, we think. More on her in What Was Ranni’s Goal?
What happens to Nepheli?
If you give Nepheli the potion Seluvis asked for, she becomes a puppet. But if you show the potion to Gideon at the Roundtable Hold first, he disposes of it, and Nepheli is spared.
Nepheli as a puppet can be obtained as a spirit in Pidia’s storeroom. The words in her puppet’s description weigh all the heavier if you know how Nepheli lived.
What the Japanese text says
This site reads the game in the original Japanese. For Seluvis, the differences are about his tastes, and they make him darker.
- Nepheli Loux Puppet. The English says she was “betrayed by her pure heart”, that she is “a diamond in the rough, deserving of special care lest its potential be squandered”, and that she “truly was a warrior”. The Japanese is 「純粋で、故に心折れた戦士の傀儡/原石は、原石であるが故に傷つきやすく/だからこそ、特に愛でる価値もあろう」: the puppet of a warrior who was pure, and therefore broken-hearted. A rough gem is easily scarred precisely because it is rough, and that is exactly why it is worth cherishing above all. The English praises her potential. The Japanese says Seluvis prizes her because she breaks easily. There is no “truly was a warrior” in the original.
- Dung Eater Puppet. 「ひたすらに醜く、忌まわしいこの傀儡は/だがその絶望故に、愛でる価値がある」: this puppet is nothing but hideous and loathsome, but because of its despair, it is worth cherishing. The Japanese keeps the same pattern as Nepheli’s: what Seluvis loves is the breaking, the despair.
- Pidia’s slip. 「き、きみ…、いえ、貴方様は…」. Pidia starts with きみ (kimi), the casual, slightly superior “you” that Seluvis always uses for the protagonist, then corrects himself to 貴方様, a very humble “your honour”. The English “Y-you! I, er, sorry, your worship” keeps the stumble, but the Japanese makes it clear that the word he nearly used is Seluvis’s own word.
- “It’s no sin, pining for a puppet to cherish.” The Japanese is simpler and creepier: 「…君ね、傀儡を愛でるのは、よいものだよ」, you know, cherishing a puppet is a fine thing.
What we still do not know
How long Pidia and Seluvis had been linked, and how, is never told. Seluvis tells you himself that he looked after Sellen when she was expelled from the Academy. Whether that is Seluvis’s own past, or Pidia’s past lived through a puppet, we cannot tell.
That Ranni had Pidia killed is also inference. The puppets may have turned on their master by themselves.
And what became of the people made into Seluvis’s puppets after Pidia’s death, the game does not show.