Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / People
Who Is Gideon Ofnir in Elden Ring? Why He Turns on You at the End, and the "End" He Feared After Touching Marika's Will
Gideon is the leader of the Tarnished at the Roundtable Hold, who sought to come close to the Elden Lordship by knowing everything. But when he touched the will of Queen Marika, he learned that knowing, and the Tarnished's fight, would both come to an "end", and he was afraid. That, we think, is why he comes at the end to stop the protagonist from becoming Elden Lord and ending the story. His words, "Queen Marika has high hopes for us. That we continue to struggle", are a misreading born of that fear.
Who is Gideon?
He is a Tarnished named in the opening, “Sir Gideon Ofnir, the all-knowing”. As the leader of the Tarnished at the Roundtable Hold, he welcomes the protagonist.
Once you have heard the Two Fingers’ words and become a true member of the Roundtable, Gideon introduces himself:
I am known as Gideon Ofnir. As a Tarnished who wishes to stand before the Elden Ring and become Elden Lord, I am accumulating knowledge. To be all-knowing. You now belong to a select group of fellows. As such, I ask that you remain constant.
—— Sir Gideon Ofnir, the All-Knowing
To be all-knowing. Gideon sought the throne not by the sword but by knowledge. He tracks down where the demigods are, gives you information, and in return asks for whatever you discover.
And at the end, in Leyndell, Ashen Capital, after the Erdtree has burned, Gideon stands in your way.
What does “the All-Knowing” mean?
His armor’s description explains his title:
Gauntlets set with countless eyes and ears. Worn by Gideon Ofnir, the All-Knowing. Knowledge begins with the recognition of one’s ignorance. The realization that the search for knowledge is unending.
The search for knowledge is unending. Knowing that is itself knowledge. Gideon placed value on the endless pursuit itself.
After the Erdtree burns, Gideon says:
The pursuit of knowledge is without end, for knowledge is never a thing complete. Thus, I maintain the mantle of All-Knowing. Perhaps the same could be said of guidance. Who’s to say whether we’ll remain who we are, once the fight is finished?
—— Sir Gideon Ofnir, the All-Knowing
“Who’s to say whether we’ll remain who we are, once the fight is finished?” The Tarnished are those called back to fight, following the guidance of grace. If the fight ended, what would the Tarnished become? That is what Gideon could not get past.
What did Gideon know?
Gideon’s words sound as though he knows things no one else does.
After you defeat Morgott, as you set out for the Mountaintops of the Giants to burn the Erdtree, Gideon tells you:
Go, if you would. Take no heed of “cardinal sin”. The Two Fingers lost their purpose a long, long time ago.
—— Sir Gideon Ofnir, the All-Knowing
The leader of the Roundtable says this of the very Two Fingers who have guided the Roundtable. Why the Two Fingers went still is covered in What Is the Greater Will?
When he is investigating Miquella, the “Queen” comes up:
How vexing. That the All-knowing didn’t have the full story… Perhaps the Queen’s sorrow was justified…
—— Sir Gideon Ofnir, the All-Knowing
Gideon seems to have known something of Queen Marika. That ties into the second half of his armor’s description.
What happened when he touched “Marika’s will”?
The All-Knowing set’s description continues:
But when Gideon glimpsed into the will of Queen Marika, he shuddered in fear. At the end that should not be.
The end that should not be.
There is no end to knowing. Gideon believed that. Yet when he touched Marika’s will, he saw an “end”.
What Marika’s will was, she never says in her own words. But looking back at what she did, we can guess. Marika shattered the Elden Ring herself, called the Tarnished back, and arranged for someone, one day, to raise the Elden Ring again. Built into her plan was an “end”: to finish a broken age and begin a new one. More in Who Is Queen Marika?
If a Tarnished becomes Elden Lord, this long fight ends. The guidance ends. And the mysteries left to know end too. That, we think, is what Gideon feared.
Why does he stand in your way at the end?
In Leyndell, Ashen Capital, Gideon waits for you with these words:
Ahh, I knew you’d come. To stand before the Elden Ring. To become Elden Lord. What a sad state of affairs. I commend your spirit, but alas, none shall take the throne. Queen Marika has high hopes for us. That we continue to struggle. Unto eternity.
—— Sir Gideon Ofnir, the All-Knowing
I commend your spirit, but none shall take the throne.
Gideon accepts that you aim to become Elden Lord. But he says it must not be achieved, because once a lord is born, the Tarnished’s fight is over.
And he calls this “Queen Marika’s” wish: that the Tarnished go on struggling, forever.
For us, this is where Gideon misreads. Marika called the Tarnished back and promised, “Return to the Lands Between, wage war, and brandish the Elden Ring.” She wanted them, one day, to raise it, not to struggle forever. Gideon, so afraid of the end, may have turned Marika’s will into “never end”.
What do his last words mean?
Defeated by the protagonist, Gideon leaves these words:
I know…in my bones… A Tarnished cannot become a Lord. Not even you. A man cannot kill a god…
—— Sir Gideon Ofnir, the All-Knowing
A man cannot kill a god.
Words fitting for the All-Knowing, who insists to the last that he “knows”. But after this, the protagonist defeats Godfrey, then Radagon and the Elden Beast, and stands before the Elden Ring. Gideon’s “I know” turns out, in the end, to be wrong.
He said there was no end to knowing, yet he never doubted what he himself knew. There is something ironic in the All-Knowing’s death.
What is he to Nepheli?
Nepheli, the warrior at the Roundtable Hold, is Gideon’s adopted daughter:
I understand you’ve been speaking to Nepheli. She is my daughter. I took her in when she lost the guidance of grace.
—— Sir Gideon Ofnir, the All-Knowing
But when Nepheli begins to doubt him, Gideon speaks coldly:
Indeed, it seemed the whelp harboured suspicions. So I had no further use for her. Honestly, what’s a man to do. A determined plebian is more wicked than an Omen horn, quite frankly. I suspect…that’s just what the Queen wants.
—— Sir Gideon Ofnir, the All-Knowing
The “Queen” appears here too. He calls the will of ordinary people a harm, and yet wonders whether that is exactly what the Queen wants. Even after learning Marika’s will, Gideon seems to have wavered to the last over how to take it.
It was Gideon, too, who disposed of the potion Seluvis meant you to give Nepheli. That is covered in Who Is Seluvis?
What the Japanese text says
This site reads the game in the original Japanese. Gideon’s key lines say something more precise there.
- “I commend your spirit, but alas, none shall take the throne.” The Japanese is 「その意志はよい、だが、達せられるべきではないのだよ」: your will is good, but it must not be fulfilled. In Japanese, Gideon does not say no one will take the throne; he says no one should. It is not a prediction but a judgement, which is why we read it as fear, not knowledge.
- “The Two Fingers lost their purpose a long, long time ago.” The Japanese is 「二本指など、とうの昔に壊れていたのだ」: the Two Fingers were broken long ago. Not “lost their purpose”, but broken, like a machine. And the dismissive など (“the likes of the Two Fingers”) shows his contempt.
- “A dose of ambition, to incite the Tarnished.” After “that’s just what the Queen wants”, the English adds this line. The Japanese has only 「我ら褪せ人にな」: from us Tarnished. Gideon does not explain what the Queen wants; he only guesses that she wants it from the Tarnished.
- “I am accumulating knowledge.” Gideon’s verb throughout is 識る (shiru), a rarer character for “to know” that means to discern, to know deeply. His title, 百智卿, is literally Lord of a Hundred Wisdoms.
What we still do not know
When and how Gideon touched Marika’s will is never told. He speaks as though he heard something, “the Queen’s sorrow”, but what that was we do not know.
What exactly the “end” Gideon feared was is also inference. The end of knowing, the end of the Tarnished’s fight, or the end of the world?
And whether Gideon’s “Queen’s wish” truly was a misreading. That Marika really did want the Tarnished to go on struggling cannot be entirely ruled out either.