Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / World & gods
What Is the Greater Will in Elden Ring? The Two Fingers and the Outer Gods, Explained
The Greater Will is a god outside the Lands Between. It sent the Elden Beast into the Lands Between, the beast became the Elden Ring, and the Golden Order began. The Two Fingers pass on its words, choose the Empyreans, and guide the Tarnished. Meanwhile, the "Outer Gods", such as the Formless Mother, the god of rot, the Twinbird and the frenzied flame, each meddle in the Lands Between on their own. Our own view is that the Greater Will is also one of the gods from outside, the one that happened to seize control of the Lands Between. That part is inference.
What is the Greater Will?
It is a god-like being outside the Lands Between. It never appears in the game.
Where it is described most clearly is the remembrance you receive for defeating the final boss, the Elden Beast:
Remembrance of the Elden Beast, hewn into the Erdtree. It was the vassal beast of the Greater Will and living incarnation of the concept of Order.
The Greater Will sent its own beast into the Lands Between. That beast was the very concept of Order, the Elden Ring. The world of the Golden Order was something the Greater Will brought in from outside.
Marika, too, was chosen by the Greater Will and became a god:
This legendary talisman is an eye engraved with an Elden Rune, said to be the seal of Queen Marika. Solemn duty weighs upon the one beholden; not unlike a gnawing curse from which there is no deliverance.
—— Marika’s Soreseal
Who are the Two Fingers?
They are the giant pair of fingers deep in the Roundtable Hold: messengers who convey the Greater Will’s words through the movement of their fingers. Finger Reader Enia, beside them, explains her role:
You’ve done well. I am Enia, the Finger Reader. I interpret the words of the Fingers, envoys to the Greater Will.
—— Finger Reader Enia
The Two Fingers also chose, from among the demigods, the candidates for the next god. Ranni says:
I was once an Empyrean. Of the demigods, only I, Miquella, and Malenia could claim that title. Each of us was chosen by our own Two Fingers, as a candidate to succeed Queen Marika, to become the new god of the coming age.
—— Ranni
“Our own Two Fingers” tells us there was not just one pair, but one for each Empyrean. And Ranni rejected hers: “I would not be controlled by that thing.” More in What Was Ranni’s Goal?
What does the Greater Will want?
Through Enia, the Two Fingers speak to the Tarnished:
“But the Greater Will has not abandoned the realm, nor the life that inhabits it.” “So it is that the Tarnished are guided by grace. Called to act.” “Brave Tarnished, your Great Rune is a handsome shard of the Elden Ring.” “Seek another of its kind.” “To become Elden Lord, and restore the Golden Order.”
—— Finger Reader Enia
The Greater Will’s wish is to restore the Golden Order: to mend the shattered Elden Ring and bring back the old order.
For that, it does not hesitate to have the demigods killed:
“The Greater Will has long renounced the demigods.” “Tarnished, show no mercy. Have their heads. Take all they have left.” “The Fingers have willed it so.”
—— Finger Reader Enia
Of Marika, it says this:
“Marika’s trespass demanded a heavy sentence.” “But even in shackles, she remains a god, and the vision’s vessel.” “Confer Great Runes to become Elden Lord, and join Queen Marika as her consort.”
—— Finger Reader Enia
Marika is punished and imprisoned in the Erdtree, yet she will still be used as a “vessel”. To the Greater Will, even a god seems to be only a tool.
Why did the Two Fingers “stop”?
Even after you defeat Morgott, the Erdtree shuts the Tarnished out with thorns. At that moment, something happens to the Two Fingers too:
You know what this means. The Erdtree has spurned you. The Fingers remain still. Shaken by this turn of events, they are busy consulting the Greater Will. When they are finished, the Fingers will again offer their guidance. But thousands, if not tens of thousands, of moons must first pass.
—— Finger Reader Enia
Things are no longer going according to the Greater Will’s plan. The Erdtree refusing the Tarnished was unforeseen even by the Greater Will.
In that situation, Enia gives the Tarnished a push:
The Fingers, dormant, severing our link to the Greater Will. The realm, and all life, in ruins. Impossible events transpire, beyond the ken of the Fingers. Who is to say that the cardinal sin must be cardinal forever? Go on. Finish the job. Take the course you deem most worthy.
—— Finger Reader Enia
From here on, the protagonist leaves the Greater Will’s guidance and burns the Erdtree by their own will.
What are the “Outer Gods”?
Besides the Greater Will, other gods meddle in the Lands Between from outside. These are the “Outer Gods”. From the item descriptions, at least four can be made out.
The first is the Formless Mother, the “mother of truth”. The god of blood and wounds worshipped by Mohg, Lord of Blood:
As well as serving as a weapon, it is an instrument of communion with an outer god who bestows power upon accursed blood. The mother of truth desires a wound.
—— Mohgwyn’s Sacred Spear
The mother of truth craves wounds. When Mohg stood before her, deep underground, his accursed blood erupted with fire, and he was besotted with the defilement that he was born into.
—— Bloodboon
The second is the god of rot. The source of the scarlet rot Malenia carried from birth:
The dancer in blue represents a fairy, who in legend bestowed a flowing sword upon a blind swordsman. Blade in hand, the swordsman sealed away an ancient god - a god that was Rot itself.
Those who dwell within poison know rot all too well. The death that begets life, that comes to all equally. That is to say: it is the cycle of rebirth put into practice.
—— Poison Armament
The third is the Twinbird. A god whose envoy is the mother of the Deathbirds:
Shield featuring a vividly painted twinbird. The twinbird is said to be the envoy of an outer god, and mother of the Deathbirds.
The fourth is the frenzied flame. The fire of chaos that dwells in the Three Fingers. A needle made by Miquella shows that the frenzied flame, too, is the meddling of an Outer God:
One of the unalloyed gold needles that Miquella crafted to ward away the meddling of outer gods. Capable of subduing the flame of frenzy if inherited, allowing one to cheat fate and avoid becoming Lord of Frenzied Flame.
—— Miquella’s Needle
More on the frenzied flame in What Is the Frenzied Flame?
Is the Greater Will one of the Outer Gods too?
From here it is inference. Our own view is that the Greater Will is also one of the Outer Gods.
Lined up, their structure is nearly identical:
| God | What it sent in from outside | Who received it |
|---|---|---|
| Greater Will | The Elden Beast (vassal beast) | Marika |
| Twinbird | The mother of the Deathbirds (envoy) | The priests of the death rites |
| Formless Mother | The bloodflame | Mohg |
| God of rot | The scarlet rot | Malenia |
| Frenzied flame | The yellow flame | The Three Fingers, the Lord of Frenzied Flame |
Each god sits outside the Lands Between, sends in an envoy or a power, and shapes the world through whoever receives it. Why only the Greater Will is the “rightful god” while the rest are called “Outer Gods”, the text does not show.
If there is a difference, it is that the Greater Will, through Marika and the Elden Ring, became the Order of the whole Lands Between. In other words, it was the god that seized control.
Seen that way, Miquella’s attempt to ward away “the meddling of outer gods” with his unalloyed gold needles takes on another meaning. Miquella was an Empyrean prepared by the Greater Will, yet he sought to become a new god free of every outer god. Including, perhaps, the Greater Will. More in What Was Miquella’s Goal?
Which god drew each demigod?
From the Outer Gods’ point of view, the demigods’ lives sort out neatly.
Mohg was drawn to the Formless Mother, Malenia to the god of rot, each from birth. Malenia fought it; Mohg accepted it and “was besotted with the defilement that he was born into”.
Ranni rejected the Greater Will and its Two Fingers, and carried her own order far away. Miquella tried to break away from every god.
The world of the Golden Order was a world the Greater Will had won, and the demigods, each drawn by a different god, spilled out beyond it. Read that way, the story of Elden Ring may also be a story of gods fighting over territory.
What the Japanese text says
This site reads the game in the original Japanese. A few lines read slightly differently there.
- “Envoys to the Greater Will.” The English makes the Fingers envoys to the Greater Will, as if they carried messages up to it. The Japanese is 「大いなる意志の使い、指様」: the Fingers, messengers of the Greater Will. In Japanese, they are plainly the Greater Will’s servants, sent down by it.
- “Shaken by this turn of events.” Enia’s Japanese is 「起こるべきでないことが起き、迷われ」: something that should never have happened has happened, and they are lost. 迷う means to be lost or at a loss. The Japanese Fingers are not merely shaken; they do not know what to do.
- “Go on. Finish the job.” The Japanese is 「…だから、あんた、やっておしまいよ/自分が正しいと思うことを、やればいいさね」, in the rough, kindly speech of an old woman: so go on, you, do it. Just do what you think is right. It reads less like an order and more like an old woman quietly letting you go.
- “The Greater Will has long renounced the demigods.” 見捨てている is has abandoned. The English “renounced” sounds formal and legal; the Japanese is the everyday word for leaving someone to their fate.
What we still do not know
What the Greater Will looks like, or where it is, is never told. Since the Elden Beast is its “vassal beast”, the Greater Will itself must be elsewhere, but beyond that we know nothing.
Whether the Two Fingers and the Three Fingers are the same kind of being is unknown too. Both take the form of “fingers”, yet one serves the Greater Will and the other the frenzied flame.
And the idea that the Greater Will is one of the Outer Gods is not written in the text. In the game, the Greater Will is always called the “Greater Will”, a different word from “Outer God”. That very distinction may mean something.