Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / People
Who Is Yura in Elden Ring? Why He Kept Chasing Eleonora, and How Shabriri Took His Body
Yura is a hunter of "Bloody Fingers", Tarnished maddened by blood. Above all, he kept chasing Eleonora, the "Violet Bloody Finger", a swordswoman of the Land of Reeds. He begs her to "yield to the cessblood no longer". His armor says he "kept a woman in the deepest reaches of his heart", and we think that woman was Eleonora. Yura was chasing her not to cut her down, but to win her back from the cessblood. But Yura falls in his fight with her, and his body is used by Shabriri, the great sinner of the frenzied flame.
Who is Yura?
He is a swordsman who appears before you again and again from early on in Limgrave. He wears a large iron woven hat and carries a fearsomely long blade on his back.
I am Yura. Hunter of Bloody Fingers. Tarnished held in thrall by cessblood. Zealots who stalk their own. If you stay the path, you are certain to face more of them. Just remember. No kinship with their ilk remains. Their madness precludes it Don’t let your emotions stay your blade.
—— Bloody Finger Hunter Yura
“Bloody Fingers” are Tarnished in thrall to cessblood who attack other Tarnished. Many of them serve Mohg, Lord of Blood. Yura hunted them, without end. More on Mohg in Who Is Mohg?
He is rough-tongued but looks out for you. At Agheel Lake he warns you away from the dragon, and if you kill it, he even tells you what to do with the dragon’s heart. To the early-game protagonist, he is like a reliable senior.
Who is Eleonora?
The one Bloody Finger Yura chased above all others was a single woman:
I’m dying to see you, Eleonora… Violet Bloody Finger… Yes, I’ve been tracking Eleonora for quite some time. She is the deadliest of all Bloody Fingers. She’s felled many an old hand already. But in spite of her cessblood zealotry, Eleonora is a proud knight.
—— Bloody Finger Hunter Yura
In spite of her cessblood zealotry, Eleonora is a proud knight. Yura, who said “No kinship with their ilk remains. Their madness precludes it”, calls Eleonora alone “proud”.
Eleonora’s weapon reads:
Twinned naginata forged in the Land of Reeds. Chosen weapon of Eleonora, Violet Bloody Finger. Her mastery of the sword was such that her onslaught was likened to a whirlwind, but now her legacy is stained by accursed blood.
—— Eleonora’s Poleblade
The Land of Reeds. Eleonora was a swordswoman from the Land of Reeds, outside the Lands Between. And Yura’s gear, too, was made to imitate the hats of the Land of Reeds. The two were swordspeople tied to the same far-off land.
Who lived in “the deepest reaches of his heart”?
This is the heart of every Yura theory.
Here is the description of Yura’s hat, which Shabriri later wears:
Iron kasa of the man who calls himself Shabriri. Crafted to imitate the woven straw hats worn in the Land of Reeds. The man, once known as Yura, kept a woman in the deepest reaches of his heart.
—— Iron Kasa
He kept a woman in the deepest reaches of his heart. Deep in his heart, he had always kept one woman. Who she was, it does not say.
But read Yura’s last words, and the answer comes into view. At the Second Church of Marika on the Altus Plateau, Yura finally fights Eleonora, and falls:
Eleonora, it seems I am no match for you. But I’ve learned a thing or two myself, you see. I’ve sliced the finger off. Please, please, Eleonora, yield to the cessblood no longer. Do not stain the immaculacy of your sword, your flesh, your fire…
—— Bloody Finger Hunter Yura
Please, Eleonora, yield to the cessblood no longer.
His last wish is not to cut her down. It is for her to give up the cessblood. For us, the woman in the deepest reaches of Yura’s heart was Eleonora. Yura was a hunter of Bloody Fingers, but the one he was really chasing was Eleonora as she was before the cessblood stained her: a proud and beautiful swordswoman.
What did Yura know about dragons?
Of the dragon at Agheel Lake, Yura said:
You’d do well to steer clear of Agheel Lake, fledgling. A dragon roosts there… And it’s as fearsome as it is majestic.
—— Bloody Finger Hunter Yura
And to the protagonist who kills the dragon, he explains where to perform “Dragon Communion”, eating the dragon’s heart. Meanwhile, what Yura begged Eleonora at the last was not to stain her “fire”. Eleonora was a swordswoman who wielded dragon flame.
When Yura spoke of dragons as “fearsome” and “majestic”, perhaps he was seeing Eleonora’s dragon flame behind them. This stays in the realm of inference, but her shadow seems to show at the edges of his words.
Why does he finally appear as Shabriri?
After Yura falls, when the protagonist reaches the Mountaintops of the Giants, a man who looks just like Yura is waiting:
Finally, we meet. The Tarnished, who would be Lord. Oh my, why the long face? I fear that you were previously acquainted with this vessel. Well, that is most unfortunate. For he is dead. As for his flesh, he gave it to me, Shabriri.
—— Shabriri
Shabriri is the great sinner said to be the origin of the frenzy sickness:
It is said that the sickness of the flame of frenzy began with Shabriri, the most reviled man in all history.
Shabriri appears by taking over the bodies of the dead. And in Yura’s body, he tempts the protagonist:
You are about to sacrifice something precious. The life of a fair maiden, that you would toss into the fiery forge. Only so that you may be Lord.
—— Shabriri
The “fair maiden” is Melina, heading to the forge as the sacrifice to burn the Erdtree. Shabriri whispers that if you do not want to sacrifice Melina, accept the frenzied flame. This whisper recalls why Vyke, the knight who once came closest to the throne, fell to the frenzied flame. More in Who Is Vyke?
Note that “he gave it to me” is Shabriri’s own claim. What kind of man Shabriri was is written in a talisman’s description:
It is said that the man, named Shabriri, had his eyes gouged out as punishment for the crime of slander, and, with time, the blight of the flame of frenzy came to dwell in the empty sockets.
—— Shabriri’s Woe
As punishment for the crime of slander. Slander means false words spoken to ruin others. Shabriri was a man punished for lies. Did Yura truly give him his body, or was his dead body simply taken? Given that Yura’s last words were a plea for Eleonora to give up the cessblood, it is hard to imagine he offered his body to the frenzied flame.
What the Japanese text says
This site reads the game in the original Japanese. Yura’s way of speaking to Eleonora is one of the clearest clues in the whole quest, and it only exists in Japanese.
- He speaks to her with honorifics. Throughout, Yura uses rough speech: 儂 for “I”, お主 for “you”. But to Eleonora alone, he uses 貴女 (anata), a respectful “you” for a woman, and polite verb endings: 「貴女には及びませぬか」, 「精進しましたぞ」, 「凶血を棄ててくだされ」. So I am still no match for you. But I have trained hard. Please, give up the cessblood. The English “I’ve learned a thing or two myself, you see” is casual. The Japanese sounds like a pupil reporting to a revered teacher, or a man speaking to someone he loves.
- His dying words. If you kill Yura, he says in English “I must not die… until she is eradicated…” The Japanese is 「…儂は、死ねぬ…/貴女を、斬るまでは…」: I cannot die… until I cut you down… It is not “she” but “you”, 貴女 again. Even dying, he speaks to Eleonora as if she were in front of him.
- “Your sword, your flesh, your fire.” The Japanese is 「貴女の剣を、体を、そして美しい竜炎を、汚さんでくだされい」: please do not stain your sword, your body, and your beautiful dragon flame. The English drops both “beautiful” and “dragon”.
- “As fearsome as it is majestic.” Of the dragon, the Japanese says 「あれは強く、美しく、そして恐ろしい」: it is strong, beautiful, and terrifying. “Beautiful” again, the same word he uses for Eleonora’s flame.
What we still do not know
What Yura and Eleonora were to each other in the Land of Reeds is never told. Master and pupil, swordspeople from the same land, or something else?
Why Eleonora fell to cessblood and became a Bloody Finger is unknown too.
And did Yura truly “give” his body to Shabriri? Can Shabriri’s words be trusted? Here readings divide from player to player.