Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / DLC
Who Is Bayle the Dread in Elden Ring? The Dragon Who Challenged the Dragonlord, and the True Origin of Dragon Communion
Bayle the Dread is "a terrible harbinger of destruction" who once challenged Placidusax, king of the ancient dragons, and fell in grievous mutual injury. To an ordinary human, "Dragon Communion", gaining power by eating a dragon's heart, looks like nothing more than a ritual of power. But the DLC reveals that the Dragon Communion priestess was once an ancient dragon who took human form to bring Bayle down. We think Dragon Communion was a technique for having humans hunt Bayle, who defied the Dragonlord, and his line. And Bayle's devoured heart, it says, still resists its subjugation, and one day will burn its devourer from within.
What kind of dragon is Bayle?
He is the vast dragon living at the top of the Jagged Peak, where lava flows, in the Realm of Shadow in Shadow of the Erdtree. He has lost his wings and arms, and is a scarred thing with bones laid bare.
A talisman in Bayle’s likeness says:
Talisman depicting the dread dragon of the jagged peak, whose roars cause the peak’s molten fury to boil and churn. Raises potency of magma. Bayle was the foul dragon’s name — a terrible harbinger of destruction whose challenge to the ancient Dragonlord ended in grievous mutual injury.
—— Talisman of the Dread
Whose challenge to the ancient Dragonlord ended in grievous mutual injury. The ancient Dragonlord is Placidusax. Bayle was a dragon who rebelled against the king of dragons. His scarred body is thought to be the mark of that battle.
What is “Dragon Communion”?
Before talking about Bayle, let us sort out “Dragon Communion”.
In the base game too, the protagonist can defeat dragons, take their hearts, and eat them at an altar to gain dragon power:
Dragon heart seized by a dragon tracker. Riddled with Gravel Stone, this grotesque organ continues to beat vivaciously. An offering used in the Dragon Communion. Consume a dragon’s heart at the altar to make its power yours. While a terrible and savage-looking thing, the heart has a peculiar beauty to it.
—— Dragon Heart
A terrible and savage-looking thing, with a peculiar beauty. Hunting a dragon, eating its heart and gaining its power. That is Dragon Communion.
Formless drakeblood seal with a dragon communion crest. Enhances Dragon Communion incantations. The sacrificial devouring of the heart gives power. Indeed, Dragon Communion is too primal in nature for the term “incantation” to be appropriate.
—— Dragon Communion Seal
Why did Dragon Communion begin?
This is the heart of every Bayle theory.
In the DLC, the protagonist meets the “Dragon Communion priestess”. Her heart’s description holds a startling fact:
The stone heart of a Dragon Communion priestess. Use while disrobed to turn one’s human flesh into an ancient dragon. The priestess was once an ancient dragon herself, but sacrificed that form for feeble flesh to aid in the destruction of Bayle the Dread.
—— Priestess Heart
She sacrificed that form for feeble flesh, to aid in the destruction of Bayle the Dread.
The Dragon Communion priestess was once an ancient dragon. And to bring Bayle down, she cast off her ancient-dragon form and became human. Her ashes say:
Long ago, Florissax assumed human form to share Dragon Communion with the world. Now, she has acquired a human heart.
—— Ancient Dragon Florissax
The priestess’s name was Florissax. And the reason she took human form was “to share Dragon Communion with the world”.
Put the two descriptions side by side: the ancient dragon Florissax took human form to bring Bayle down, and shared Dragon Communion with humans. In other words, Dragon Communion was a technique born to bring Bayle down.
Humans grow stronger if they eat a dragon’s heart. Seeking that power, humans begin to hunt dragons. And so humans are made to hunt Bayle, who defied the Dragonlord, and his kin. Dragon Communion, we think, was a punishment by the dragons themselves on a dragon who defied the king of the ancient dragons.
What does the Communion heart want?
When the protagonist defeats Bayle, they get Bayle’s heart:
The biatrial heart of Bayle the Dread. Dotted with horn-like gravel stones and glistening with deep-red liquor. Gorge upon this at the Grand Altar of Dragon Communion to absorb Bayle’s power. The purest form of Communion, in the words of its priestess.
—— Heart of Bayle
The purest form of Communion. To the Dragon Communion priestess, having Bayle’s heart eaten was the final goal of Dragon Communion itself.
But the power of the devoured Bayle comes with an ominous line:
One of the greatest Dragon Communion incantations. Harnesses the fearsome power of Bayle the Dread. Even after being consumed, the throbbing heart of Bayle continues to resist its subjugation, never weakening. One day, the fire within will consume the very body and soul of its Communion devourer. One day.
—— Bayle’s Tyranny
Even after being consumed, the heart continues to resist its subjugation. Bayle has not bowed, even after being eaten. The rebel who defied the Dragonlord keeps rebelling, even as a heart. Whoever takes in a dragon’s power will one day be burned from within by that dragon. This, we think, is the line that best captures both the beauty and the horror of Dragon Communion.
Who is Igon?
In the battle with Bayle, an old warrior lends you his strength: Igon, the drake warrior.
Weapon of Igon, the broken drake warrior. A greatbow fashioned from two dragon bones bound with coarse rope. Covered in gashes left by claws.
—— Igon’s Greatbow
Great arrow that bristles with sharp gravel stone pieces. Has an anti-dragon effect. The broken drake warrior Igon made these one by one in the midst of his agony—so that Bayle the Dread himself would know fear.
—— Igon’s Harpoon
So that Bayle the Dread himself would know fear. Igon was a drake warrior who once challenged Bayle and was broken in body and mind. He made a bow from dragon bones and arrows from the gravel stones of dragon hearts. He is what a human on the road of Dragon Communion becomes.
And Igon meant to cross from the side that had fear planted in it to the side that plants fear. Igon’s cry in the Bayle fight is one of the most memorable moments in the DLC.
How does this tie to the base game’s dragons?
The base game has many stories of Dragon Communion and the ancient dragons:
- The drakes found across the Lands Between are thought to be of Bayle’s line
- Vyke, Knight of the Roundtable, was “the one Lansseax loved the most”. More in Who Is Vyke?
- In the base game, Yura tells you where to eat a dragon’s heart. More in Who Is Yura?
Dragons are strong, beautiful, and terrifying. And Dragon Communion gives humans the dragons’ power, in exchange drawing them closer to being dragons.
What the Japanese text says
This site reads the game in the original Japanese. The priestess’s purpose, in particular, is stated more starkly there.
- “To aid in the destruction of Bayle the Dread.” The Priestess Heart’s Japanese is 「凶なる竜ベールを討つ、ただそのために/自らを捧げ、弱き姿を受け容れたのだ」: for that alone, to strike down Bayle, the ill-omened dragon, she gave herself up and accepted a feeble form. ただそのために means for that purpose and nothing else. The English “to aid in” makes her a helper; the Japanese makes destroying Bayle her single reason for becoming human.
- “Dragon heart seized by a dragon tracker.” The Japanese is 「竜狩りの果実たる、竜の心臓」: a dragon’s heart, the fruit of the dragon hunt. The heart is called a fruit, something harvested, which fits the idea that Dragon Communion turned dragons into crops for humans to reap.
- “A terrible harbinger of destruction.” The talisman’s Japanese is 「怒れる破壊者」: an enraged destroyer. Not a harbinger, a sign of disaster to come, but an angry being who destroys. The anger is in the name.
- “Ended in grievous mutual injury.” 「共に傷つき倒れた」: both were wounded and fell. Plain and equal: the Dragonlord fell too.
What we still do not know
Why Bayle defied Dragonlord Placidusax is not written.
Whether the base game’s drakes really are of Bayle’s line has not been clearly confirmed in the text either.
And will the one who ate Bayle’s heart truly be burned from within one day? It says only “one day”, and the game does not show that end.