Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / DLC

Shadow of the Erdtree Story Explained. The Realm of Shadow, the Scadutree and Miquella's Crosses

Updated: 2026-10-25
Beyond a Tarnished on a spectral steed, the vast Scadutree and a castle rise
The Realm of Shadow and the Scadutree, the setting of the DLC Image: ELDEN RING official website ©Bandai Namco Entertainment Inc. / ©2022 FromSoftware, Inc.
The short answer Confirmed in text

The DLC is two stories laid over each other. One is Miquella's journey through the Realm of Shadow, abandoning his flesh, his heart, even his love, to become a god. The other is the story of what Marika did in the Realm of Shadow before she became a god. The Realm of Shadow is where Marika hid "the original sin" and "a hatred that would not be confined", and the Scadutree, born of those dark notions, was the Erdtree's shadow.

What is the DLC about?

After defeating Mohg, Lord of Blood, in the base game, touch the cocoon left in the Mohgwyn Palace, and you cross into the setting of the DLC: the Realm of Shadow.

Miquella, who should have been inside the cocoon, is no longer there. He has cast off his body and set out for the Realm of Shadow. The protagonist follows in his footsteps.

In the Realm of Shadow you meet Miquella’s followers: Leda the Needle Knight, and others who have trailed him there. They too are travelling to learn what Miquella means to do.

The flow of the story is simple. Follow Miquella, cross the Realm of Shadow, and at last, at Enir-Ilim, the gate of divinity, face Miquella, about to become a god, and Radahn, welcomed as his lord. Along the way, the past of the Realm of Shadow itself, which is to say Marika’s past, slowly comes to light.

What is the Realm of Shadow?

It is the land where Marika lived before she became a god. Her home, the shaman village, is here.

And after Marika became a god, she veiled this land, making it a place the people of the Lands Between could not see. The remembrance of her son Messmer hints at why:

A malevolent snake writhed within Messmer, and so his very mother plucked out his eye and put in its place a seal of grace. Yet, having done so, her fear compelled her to secret away her child within the realm of shadow. Hidden away—keeping company with the original sin, and a hatred that would not be confined.

—— Remembrance of the Impaler

The original sin, and a hatred that would not be confined. Marika hid more than Messmer in the Realm of Shadow. The sin she committed on her way to godhood, and the hatred she could not let go of. We think she sank all of it into shadow, along with the land itself.

Marika’s origins and the tragedy of her home are covered in detail in Who Is Queen Marika?

What is the Scadutree?

In the Realm of Shadow stands a great tree unlike the Erdtree: the Scadutree. The remembrance you receive for defeating its avatar says what it is:

The Scadutree is the shadow of the Erdtree. Born of dark notions that bear no sense of Order, that twist and bend its stock, rendering it brittle.

—— Remembrance of the Shadow Sunflower

The Erdtree’s shadow. A tree born of dark notions that bear no sense of Order.

Whose dark notions, it does not say. But given that the Realm of Shadow is where Marika hid “the original sin” and “a hatred that would not be confined”, the natural reading is that the Scadutree grew from Marika’s own dark notions.

If the Erdtree is Marika’s public face, the Scadutree is her hidden one. Order in the light; in the shadow, the hatred that could never become Order. Marika may have divided herself between two trees.

What did Messmer do in the Realm of Shadow?

Marika’s son Messmer burned the Realm of Shadow at his mother’s wish:

On his mother’s wishes, Messmer made himself a symbol of fear, undertaking the cleansing crusade she desired. “Direct thy maledictions, thine ire, and thy grief towards me alone.”

—— Messmer’s armor

Those burned were the Hornsent who lived in the Realm of Shadow. Long before, they had taken the shamans of the shaman village and used them in their jar rituals. They were the enemies of Marika’s home.

For his mother’s wish, Messmer took every grudge upon himself alone. And still Marika left him behind in the Realm of Shadow. He is one of the least rewarded figures in the DLC.

There is one more important thing we learn about Messmer:

Messmer, much like his younger sister, bore a vision of fire.

—— Messmer’s Kindling

This “younger sister” is most likely Melina. More in Who Is Melina?

What did Miquella abandon in the Realm of Shadow?

This, we think, is the part of the DLC that cuts deepest.

All across the Realm of Shadow stand places called Miquella’s Crosses, thirteen in all. Stand before one, and the carved words rise up:

Carved words coalesce. “I abandon here the first of the flesh of my body.”

—— Miquella’s Cross

“I abandon here my arm sinistral.”

—— Miquella’s Cross

“I abandon here my heart.”

—— Miquella’s Cross

“I abandon here my eye.”

—— Miquella’s Cross

As he crossed the Realm of Shadow, Miquella abandoned himself, piece by piece. Flesh, arm, heart, eye. And not only his body:

“I abandon here my doubt and vacillation.”

—— Miquella’s Cross

“I abandon here my love.”

—— Miquella’s Cross

I abandon here my love.

Miquella had the power of “charm”, which turned the hearts of those he met toward himself. At the root of that power, surely, was Miquella’s own love. To become a god, he abandoned even that.

The last cross stands within Enir-Ilim, the gate of divinity:

“I abandon here all my fears.”

—— Miquella’s Cross

Miquella’s Great Rune states the purpose of this journey plainly:

Miquella set off for the tower enshrouded by shadow, abandoning everything—his golden flesh, his blinding strength, even his fate. All in an effort to bury the original sin. To embrace the whole of it, and be reborn as a new god.

—— Miquella’s Great Rune

To become a god who embraces everything, abandon everything of yourself. It sounds like a contradiction, but for Miquella it was the only road. More in What Was Miquella’s Goal?

A Tarnished unleashing a fire incantation against soldiers in golden armour
Battle in the Realm of ShadowImage: ELDEN RING official website ©Bandai Namco Entertainment Inc. / ©2022 FromSoftware, Inc.

What happened to Miquella’s followers?

Many of those following Miquella through the Realm of Shadow had gathered because of his charm.

Leda the Needle Knight is the foremost of them. Her sword reads:

Light greatsword with gold inlaid. Weapon of Leda, the Needle Knight. Deals holy damage. Though polished to a mirror sheen, this blade still reeks with the stench of crusted blood that lingers from the cull of her knightly comrades.

—— Leda’s Sword

For Miquella’s sake, she would cut down even her former comrades. That is what it looked like to be charmed. Late in the DLC, the followers turn their blades on one another over their differing feelings for Miquella.

And there is one more enigmatic figure: St. Trina.

St. Trina is an enigmatic figure. Some say she is a comely young girl, others are sure he is a boy. The only certainty is that their appearance was as sudden as their disappearance.

—— Sword of St. Trina

A saint of sleep, said to be a girl, said to be a boy. St. Trina is thought to be another face of Miquella, or a half he cut away from himself. Perhaps Trina was one of the things Miquella abandoned to become a god.

What happened at the end?

At the summit of Enir-Ilim, the protagonist meets Miquella, and Radahn, revived as his lord. Radahn’s soul had been called back using Mohg’s body as its vessel.

The remembrance you receive afterwards tells how Miquella’s wish began:

In their childhood, Miquella saw in Radahn a lord. His strength, and his kindness, that stood in stark contrast with their afflicted selves. And so Miquella made his heartfelt wish. That Radahn would one day be his king consort.

—— Remembrance of a God and a Lord

And the incantation of Miquella’s power says where that wish led:

Miquella sought to accept all that was and would be, but found one that refused to be embraced. No wonder, as one god and one king consort, is all the world needs.

—— Light of Miquella

In English this reads as fulfilment: one god, one consort. The original Japanese says the opposite, and it changes the ending. See the next section.

What the Japanese text says

This site reads the game in the original Japanese. For the DLC, the differences are not small.

  • Light of Miquella. The Japanese reads 「ミケラは、全てを受け容れ、抱こうと望み/だがひとつだけ、そうできぬものを知っていた/絶対の神も、その王も/決して並び立つことはない」: Miquella wished to accept and embrace all, but he knew of one thing he could not. An absolute god and its king can never stand side by side. The lord he wished for as a child, and the god Miquella became, can never be equals. The lord he welcomed, at the cost of abandoning his love, was no longer his equal. In Japanese, the DLC ends by showing that Miquella’s wish was broken at the very moment it came true.
  • Remembrance of the Impaler. The English gives Marika a motive: “her fear compelled her to secret away her child”. The Japanese has no fear in it: 「母は、その瞳を封印の祝福に入れ替え/それでもなお、彼を影に隠した」, his mother replaced his eye with a sealing grace, and even so, she hid him in the shadow. The Japanese leaves her reason unsaid.
  • Miquella’s Great Rune. “To bury the original sin” is 「はじまりから続く因果を超えて」: to go beyond the chain of cause and effect that has run since the beginning. It is not about burying a sin, but about breaking free of fate itself.
  • Miquella’s Crosses. The English “I abandon here” is 「ここに棄てる」. 棄てる is the formal, heavier character for “throw away”, the one used for abandoning a child or a homeland, not for discarding rubbish. Several crosses also read 「我が肉体を削り、ここに棄てる」, I pare away my flesh, and abandon it here. The English “a part of the flesh of my body” loses the image of carving himself away.

What did the DLC reveal about the base game?

The DLC was a new story, and at the same time a check of answers to the base game’s mysteries.

Base-game mysteryWhat the DLC revealedMore
Where did Marika come from?The shaman village in the Realm of ShadowWho Is Queen Marika?
Why did Marika break the Golden Order?In secret, she prayed for “the kindness of gold, without Order”Who Is Queen Marika?
Who is Melina?Messmer’s “younger sister”, meaning Marika’s daughterWho Is Melina?
What did Miquella want?To become a new god who embraces all, with Radahn as his lordWhat Was Miquella’s Goal?
Was there another Lord of Frenzied Flame?Midra, Lord of Frenzied Flame, in the Realm of ShadowWhat Is the Frenzied Flame?

What we still do not know

Whose dark notions gave birth to the Scadutree? Marika is the natural reading, but the text does not say so.

Whether Miquella truly became a god is not clear either. Defeated by the protagonist, his plan seems to end there.

The same goes for St. Trina. The same being as Miquella, or a different one? The DLC ends without saying much.

And what was the “original sin” that Marika hid in the Realm of Shadow? The crusade against the Hornsent, or something from even earlier? The DLC brought us closer to answers, and in doing so, we think, added new mysteries of its own.