Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / DLC
Who Is Messmer in Elden Ring? The Serpent Sealed in His Eye, and Why He Cursed His Mother Marika at the End
Messmer is Marika's son, born with a "malevolent snake" inside his body. Marika replaced his eye with a seal of grace, hid him in the Realm of Shadow, and left him the crusade against the Hornsent. For his mother's wish he made himself a symbol of fear, and kept up the crusade even after she abandoned him. His last words, "A curse upon thee", are, we think, the feelings for his mother he had held down for so long, finally put into words. Because he loved her, cursing her was all that was left.
Who is Messmer?
He is the demigod who ruled the Realm of Shadow, the setting of Shadow of the Erdtree. Queen Marika’s son, called “the Impaler”.
When he faces the protagonist in Shadow Keep, Messmer says:
Mongrel intruder. Thou’rt… Tarnished, it seemth. Mother, wouldst thou truly Lordship sanction, in one so bereft of light? Yet… My purpose standeth unchanged. Those stripped of the Grace of Gold shall all meet death. In the embrace of Messmer’s flame.
—— Messmer the Impaler
Those stripped of the Grace of Gold shall all meet death. Messmer bore the duty of burning all who lacked the grace of gold. That duty was given to him by his mother, Marika.
What was the “malevolent snake” inside him?
The remembrance you receive for defeating Messmer tells of his birth:
A malevolent snake writhed within Messmer, and so his very mother plucked out his eye and put in its place a seal of grace. Yet, having done so, her fear compelled her to secret away her child within the realm of shadow. Hidden away—keeping company with the original sin, and a hatred that would not be confined.
Messmer was born with a “malevolent snake” inside his body. To hold it down, Marika replaced his eye with a “seal of grace”. Even that was not enough, and she hid Messmer in the Realm of Shadow.
Beside Messmer there were always winged serpents:
The winged snakes were Messmer’s constant companions. They were there when the base serpent was sealed away behind his eye. They were there through his eternity of suffering. They will accompany him yet, in his hideous new form born when he destroyed the grace granted by his mother. They have accepted his fate as much as he.
—— Messmer’s Helm

In the Japanese Fire Knight gear, these winged serpents are described as friends of good intellect who keep the base serpent in check and hold back its power. The serpent inside Messmer was evil; the serpents outside him were friends. Messmer lived his whole life surrounded by serpents, and tormented by one.
What did Messmer do?
The duty Marika gave Messmer was the crusade against the Hornsent of the Realm of Shadow. From his armor:
On his mother’s wishes, Messmer made himself a symbol of fear, undertaking the cleansing crusade she desired. “Direct thy maledictions, thine ire, and thy grief towards me alone.”
—— Messmer’s armor
Direct thy maledictions, thine ire, and thy grief towards me alone. To grant his mother’s wish, Messmer resolved to carry every grudge by himself. Even the dreadful name “the Impaler” was a disgrace he chose for himself.
Why Marika wanted the Hornsent purged is covered in Who Is Queen Marika? Marika’s home, the shaman village, had suffered at the Hornsent’s hands. The crusade seems to have been Marika’s revenge, once she became a god.
How did Messmer feel about his own fire?
Messmer’s flame is the power of “fire”, forbidden in the Lands Between. But Messmer himself hated that fire:
Messmer despised his own fire. Time and time again he hoped to rid himself of it, but ever did it burn.
—— Messmer’s Orb
And the kindling that burned inside his body says:
The kindling that burned inside Messmer the Impaler, a dark thing, eaten away at by a wicked serpent. Messmer, much like his younger sister, bore a vision of fire.
—— Messmer’s Kindling
Much like his younger sister. Messmer had a younger sister who also bore a vision of fire. She is most likely Melina, who became the kindling that burned the Erdtree. More in Who Is Melina?
The brother wielded fire in the Realm of Shadow; the sister gave herself to the fire in the Lands Between. Of Marika’s children, the two who carried fire both spent it for their mother’s plan.
Who served Messmer?
Messmer was not simply feared. The gear of those who served him carries their loyalty to him:
Each and every knight hailed from a renowned family of the Erdtree’s upper echelons, but were shunned and chased from their homes after pledging allegiance to Messmer as their master.
—— Fire Knight set
These were the only ones who truly knew Messmer. His flames, like serpents. The painful fate that accompanied his accursed form.
—— Fire Knight Armor
The Fire Knights were people who gave up their standing as Erdtree nobility to follow Messmer. And only they knew Messmer truly.
The Black Knights, the main force of Messmer’s army, did not:
Though he remained a devout follower of Messmer after his flight from the Erdtree, he would rebel after learning of his liege’s serpentine nature. His righteous stand was rewarded with imprisonment in an underground tomb.
—— Black Knight Commander Andreas
Though a champion of the divine beast hunt, he followed his father, Andreas, into rebellion against Messmer, and like his father, he too was imprisoned in an underground tomb. Messmer mourned the loss of a brother-in-arms.
—— Black Knight Captain Huw
Messmer mourned the loss of a brother-in-arms. Subordinates who rebelled once they learned what he was, Messmer did not kill but imprisoned, and then mourned. He called himself a symbol of fear, yet could not bear losing his comrades.
Messmer had one more friend: the boar-riding commander, Gaius.
Both were as elder brothers to the lion, and both were cursed from birth. In spite of, or perhaps because of this very reason, Gaius was both Messmer’s friend and the leader of his men.
—— Remembrance of the Wild Boar Rider
“The lion” reads as Radahn, known as the red lion. Messmer and Gaius were both like elder brothers to Radahn, and both were called cursed from birth.
What happens in the middle of the fight?
When Messmer is pushed back in his fight with the protagonist, a cutscene plays:
I will not suffer… A lord devoid of light. O mother, forgive me.
—— Messmer the Impaler
Then Messmer reaches for his own eye, pulls out the seal of grace his mother put there, and destroys it:
Soon, Tarnished. Wilt thou be taken in the jaws… Of the abyssal serpent, shorn of light.
—— Messmer the Impaler
O mother, forgive me. To break, with his own hand, the seal his mother placed. That was a betrayal of her wish. And yet Messmer broke his mother’s seal to fulfil “his mother’s purpose”: never to let one bereft of light become lord. To keep his mother’s wish, he cast away his mother’s grace. Messmer’s last battle sits inside that contradiction.
Why did he curse his mother at the end?
Defeated by the protagonist, Messmer leaves these last words:
Mother… Marika… A curse…upon thee…
—— Messmer the Impaler
He calls her “Mother”, then corrects himself to her name, “Marika”. The curse is aimed not at his mother, but at Marika the god.
This is the heart of every Messmer theory.
Why would a son who carried everything for his mother curse her at the end? There are two main readings.
One is that the grudge he had held down finally came out. Born with a serpent inside him, his eye replaced, hidden in shadow, given the dirty work, then abandoned. Messmer had swallowed all of it, “towards me alone”, and only at death spoke his true feelings for the first time.
The other is that it was his last wish for his mother. When Messmer said “Direct thy maledictions towards me alone”, receiving curses was his role. Cursing his mother at the end can be read as the moment he stopped taking her sins upon himself.
For us, it is not one or the other. Messmer loved his mother. Because he loved her, he could become a symbol of fear for her. And because he loved her, at the end, cursing her was all that was left. If he had felt nothing for her, he would have had no reason to curse her at all.
The man who said “O mother, forgive me” mid-battle says “a curse upon thee” at the end. Messmer turned both the plea for forgiveness and the curse toward his mother.
What was “the original sin”?
Back to the last line of the remembrance: “Hidden away—keeping company with the original sin, and a hatred that would not be confined.”
What are “the original sin” and “a hatred that would not be confined”, hidden in shadow together with Messmer? The text never says clearly.
We read them as the sin Marika committed on her way to godhood, and her hatred for the Hornsent who tormented her home. Marika hid the dark part of her past, the past that made her a god, together with the Realm of Shadow, and together with Messmer. Messmer was a son made to carry his mother’s sin.
But “the original sin” can also be read as Messmer himself, born with a serpent inside. To Marika, Messmer’s very existence may have been a sin she wanted hidden.
What the Japanese text says
This site reads the game in the original Japanese. For Messmer, several of the most important lines differ.
- His last words. The English is “Mother… Marika… A curse…upon thee…” The Japanese is 「…母よ、マリカよ/私は、呪う。貴方を…」: O mother, O Marika. I curse you… In Japanese, the subject 私 (“I”) is spoken. It is not a curse falling on her from somewhere; it is Messmer himself, choosing to curse her.
- Remembrance of the Impaler. The English gives Marika a motive: “her fear compelled her to secret away her child”. The Japanese is 「母は、その瞳を封印の祝福に入れ替え/それでもなお、彼を影に隠した」: his mother replaced his eye with a sealing grace, and even so, she hid him in the shadow. No fear is mentioned. The Japanese “even so” makes it colder: the serpent was sealed, and she hid him anyway.
- Fire Knight Armor. The English reads “His flames, like serpents.” The Japanese is 「その蛇たるを。蛇たる苦悩を」: that he was a serpent. The anguish of being a serpent. In Japanese, the Fire Knights knew Messmer’s secret, that he himself was a serpent, which is exactly what the Black Knights rebelled over. The English loses that link.
- Messmer’s Helm. “They have accepted his fate as much as he” is, in Japanese, 「母の祝福を壊し、自らの宿命を受け容れた/おぞましい姿の後も」: even after the hideous form he took when he broke his mother’s grace and accepted his own fate. In Japanese, it is Messmer who accepts his fate, by breaking the seal.
- Messmer’s Orb. The English ends “but ever did it burn”. The Japanese ends with Messmer’s effort, not the result: 「故に幾度となく、それを潰し/消し去ろうとした」, so time and again he crushed it, and tried to extinguish it.
What we still do not know
Who Messmer’s father is, is never told. Is he the son of Godfrey or Radagon, Marika’s husbands, or of someone else? Where the “malevolent snake” inside him came from is unknown too.
When and why Marika abandoned Messmer is not clearly written either.
And how is the “abyssal serpent” related to the great serpent Rykard became in the base game, or to the serpents of the Volcano Manor? They are all serpents, but we have found no text linking them.