Kousatsu Note / Harry Potter / Mysteries
Harry Potter Foreshadowing: The Setups From Book 1 and How the Final Book Paid Them Off
Harry Potter is full of setups planted from book 1 and paid off in book 7. The best known: Snape protecting Harry (from the first Quidditch match), why Harry can talk to snakes (the piece of Voldemort's soul inside him), Harry catching the Snitch in his mouth in book 1 (it opens in book 7), the Sword of Gryffindor soaking up basilisk venom (which is why it can destroy Horcruxes) and the diadem Harry leaves in the Room of Requirement in book 6 (a Horcrux itself).
This article contains spoilers for all seven books. It’s for people who have finished the books or films.
What setups involve Snape?
| Setup | Planted | Paid off | What it turned out to be |
|---|---|---|---|
| At a Quidditch match, Snape stares at Harry and mutters something | Book 1 | End of book 1, book 7 | Quirrell was cursing Harry. Snape was saying a counter-curse to protect him |
| Snape’s fixation on Harry’s eyes | From book 1 | Book 7 | Harry’s eyes are green, like Lily’s |
| Dumbledore never tells anyone why he trusts Snape | From book 4 | Book 7 | Snape’s love for Lily and his promise to Dumbledore |
| The doe Patronus that leads Harry to the pool | Book 7 | Book 7 | Snape’s Patronus, the same shape as Lily’s |
| The “Half-Blood Prince” in the old textbook | Book 6 | End of book 6 | Snape himself, named after his mother’s maiden name, Prince |
More on Snape in the Snape article.
What setups involve the Horcruxes?
| Setup | Planted | Paid off | What it turned out to be |
|---|---|---|---|
| Harry can talk to snakes | Book 1 (the zoo), book 2 | Book 7 | A piece of Voldemort’s soul was inside him |
| The diary is a “memory” but thinks and acts on its own | Book 2 | Book 6 | It was the first Horcrux he made |
| A locket nobody can open in a cabinet at Grimmauld Place | Book 5 | Book 7 | Slytherin’s locket itself |
| The old diadem Harry puts on a bust to mark where he hid the textbook in the Room of Requirement | Book 6 | Book 7 | Ravenclaw’s diadem, a Horcrux |
| Dumbledore’s blackened, withered hand | Book 6 | Book 7 | The curse on the Horcrux ring |
| Harry kills the basilisk with the Sword of Gryffindor | Book 2 | Book 7 | The sword soaked up the venom and became able to destroy Horcruxes |
The full list is in the Horcrux article.
What setups involve the Deathly Hallows?
| Setup | Planted | Paid off | What it turned out to be |
|---|---|---|---|
| An Invisibility Cloak arrives at Christmas from an unknown sender | Book 1 | Book 7 | Harry’s father’s cloak, which Dumbledore had been keeping. One of the Hallows |
| Harry catches the Snitch in his mouth in his first match | Book 1 | Book 7 | A Snitch remembers who first touched it. The Snitch Dumbledore leaves Harry shows words when Harry puts it to his lips |
| Dumbledore says he sees socks in the Mirror of Erised | Book 1 | Book 7 | It reads as if he really saw the family he lost |
| Harry’s wand and Voldemort’s are brothers | Book 1 | Books 4 and 7 | Both hold a feather from the same phoenix, Fawkes. The spells connect in the graveyard in book 4 |
| The crest on the ring’s stone at the Gaunt house | Book 6 | Book 7 | The sign of the Hallows. It was the Resurrection Stone |
More in the Deathly Hallows article.
What setups involve the characters?
| Setup | Planted | Paid off | What it turned out to be |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ron’s rat Scabbers is missing a toe | From book 1 | Book 3 | He was Peter Pettigrew, who faked his death leaving only a finger behind |
| Hagrid mentions borrowing a motorbike from Sirius Black | Book 1 | Book 3 | Sirius was Harry’s godfather |
| Professor Lupin is off sick around the full moon | Book 3 | Book 3 | He was a werewolf |
| Neville was also born at the end of July | Book 5 | Books 5 and 7 | The prophecy could have meant Neville. In book 7 he kills Nagini, the last Horcrux |
| A blue eye in the shard of Sirius’s two-way mirror | Book 7 | Book 7 | The eye of Dumbledore’s brother Aberforth |
| In book 4, Dumbledore’s eyes gleam when he hears Voldemort used Harry’s blood | Book 4 | Book 7 | It’s why Harry survives in the forest |
The last one is explained in the why Harry survived article.
My personal favorite is the Snitch in book 1. In his first Quidditch match, Harry nearly swallows it. When I first read it, it was just a funny moment. I never expected book 7 to come back to it.
Is anything still unanswered?
As a series of novels, it’s finished, and there are almost no big mysteries left.
The Fantastic Beasts films, though, were announced as five films and stopped at three. Dumbledore’s duel with Grindelwald in 1945 has never been shown on screen.