Kousatsu Note / Harry Potter / Hidden identities

FilmsHarry Potter Hidden identities

Was Snape Good or Bad? His Love for Lily, the Double Agent Truth and Which Book Reveals It

Updated: 2026-10-31
The short answer Confirmed in text

Snape was on Harry's side to the end. He was a double agent, posing as one of Voldemort's Death Eaters while working for Dumbledore. The reason was that he had always loved Harry's mother, Lily. After Voldemort killed her, Snape promised Dumbledore he would protect her son. He killed Dumbledore because Dumbledore himself asked him to. The truth comes out in book 7, Deathly Hallows (Deathly Hallows – Part 2 in the films), through the memories Snape gives Harry as he dies.

This article covers the ending of book 7, Deathly Hallows.

Was Snape the enemy?

No. He protected Harry the whole way through.

From book 1 to book 6, Snape is a horrible teacher as far as Harry is concerned. He never gives Harry a break and seems to have it in for him. At the end of book 6 he kills Dumbledore, and Harry decides once and for all that Snape is the enemy.

But in book 7, as Voldemort is killing him, Snape hands his memories to Harry. When Harry looks into them, he finds that Snape had been working for Dumbledore all along.

Why did he protect Harry?

Because he had loved Harry’s mother, Lily, since they were children.

Snape and Lily were friends before either of them went to Hogwarts. At school, though, Snape got drawn into the Dark Arts, and he and Lily went separate ways. Lily married James Potter, whom Snape couldn’t stand.

Snape became a Death Eater and passed a prophecy on to Voldemort: a child would be born who could defeat him. Voldemort decided the child was Lily’s son Harry and went after the Potters.

When Snape realized he had put Lily in danger, he went to Dumbledore and begged him to protect her. Lily was killed anyway. After that, Snape promised Dumbledore he would protect her son.

What did the doe Patronus mean?

Snape’s Patronus was a doe, the same shape as Lily’s.

In book 7, a doe leads Harry to the Sword of Gryffindor at the bottom of a frozen pool. Harry has no idea whose Patronus it is. In the memories, Dumbledore sees Snape’s Patronus and asks whether he still feels that way about Lily after all this time, and Snape says always. That answer ties everything together.

Why did he kill Dumbledore?

Because Dumbledore asked him to.

Before book 6, Dumbledore had been hit by the curse on a ring that was one of the Horcruxes. That’s why his hand was blackened and withered. He didn’t have long to live.

Meanwhile, Voldemort had ordered Draco Malfoy to kill Dumbledore. Dumbledore didn’t want Draco to become a killer. And if Snape killed him, Voldemort would trust Snape completely. So Dumbledore asked Snape to kill him when the time came.

How did Snape die?

Late in book 7, Voldemort decides the Elder Wand, Dumbledore’s old wand, won’t work properly for him because Snape, who killed Dumbledore, has become its master. So he sets his snake Nagini on Snape.

In fact, Snape was never the wand’s master. He was killed over a mistake. That part is explained in the why Harry survived article.

As he dies, Snape gives Harry his memories and looks into Harry’s eyes. They are green, like Lily’s.

Was Snape a good person?

Honestly, you can’t call him a good person.

At school he was obsessed with the Dark Arts, and he became a Death Eater. As a teacher he kept treating Harry and Neville badly. His feelings for Lily were sincere, but his grudge against Harry’s father James spilled over onto the son.

Even so, Snape protected Harry for almost twenty years without telling anyone the truth. Personally, I think that’s where the real weight of the character lies. Not a good man, but a brave one. In the end Harry gives one of his own children Snape’s name.

Which book and film reveal it?

BookFilm
Kills DumbledoreEnd of book 6, Half-Blood PrinceHalf-Blood Prince
The doe PatronusMiddle of book 7, Deathly HallowsDeathly Hallows – Part 1
The memories that reveal the truthNear the end of book 7Deathly Hallows – Part 2