Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / DLC
Who Is Metyr, Mother of Fingers, in Elden Ring? Why the Mother of the Two Fingers Kept Waiting for the Greater Will "Despite Being Broken and Abandoned"
Metyr, Mother of Fingers, is the mother of all Two Fingers and of the finger-shaped creatures called Fingercreepers. She was a "magnificently gleaming daughter of the Greater Will" and "the first shooting star to fall upon the Lands Between." Metyr received signs from the Greater Will through her microcosm. But even after being broken and abandoned, she kept waiting for another message. The Two Fingers, who pass on the Greater Will's words, were not linked to that will directly, but through their "mother". And even that mother had been abandoned. Metyr, we think, is a sign that the Greater Will, which was supposed to be watching over the Lands Between, may already have withdrawn from them. In the Realm of Shadow, the former sorcery teacher Count Ymir was trying to take Metyr's place as "the true mother".
What is Metyr, Mother of Fingers?
In the Realm of Shadow, in the DLC SHADOW OF THE ERDTREE, there are several strange ruins shaped like fingers. Ring the bell in one of them, and in a deep blue space, something enormous is waiting.
A body like countless fingers tangled together. A black sphere floating above it. Her name is “Metyr, Mother of Fingers”. The remembrance you get for defeating her says:
Remembrance of Metyr, Mother of Fingers, hewn into the Scadutree (snip) The mother of all Two Fingers and Fingercreepers was in turn a magnificently gleaming daughter of the Greater Will, and the first shooting star to fall upon the Lands Between.
—— Remembrance of the Mother of Fingers
The mother of all Two Fingers and Fingercreepers was in turn a magnificently gleaming daughter of the Greater Will, and the first shooting star to fall upon the Lands Between.
The Two Fingers, who passed on the Greater Will’s words at the Roundtable Hold in the base game. Their mother was Metyr. And Metyr was a “daughter” of the Greater Will, the “first shooting star” to fall from the sky onto the Lands Between.
How is she related to the Two Fingers?
The Two Fingers are messengers who pass on the Greater Will’s words through the movement of fingers. At the back of the Roundtable Hold, Enia the Finger Reader read those words. More on the Two Fingers in What Is the Greater Will?
With Metyr, the link between the Greater Will and the Lands Between comes into a little sharper focus.
There is the Greater Will, there is its daughter the Mother of Fingers, and there are the Two Fingers born from that mother. The Two Fingers were not connected to the Greater Will directly; they received its words through their mother.
What shows that mechanism is a staff made from Metyr’s tail-fingers:
Staff fashioned from the tail-fingers of Metyr, the Mother of Fingers, and the microcosm raised aloft over the crux they form. Catalyst for casting both sorceries and incantations. The Mother received signs from the Greater Will from the beyond of the microcosm. Despite being broken and abandoned, she kept waiting for another message to come.
—— Staff of the Great Beyond
The Mother received signs from the Greater Will from the beyond of the microcosm.
The black sphere floating above Metyr was a “microcosm”. Through it, Metyr received signs from the Greater Will.
What does “despite being broken and abandoned” mean?
This is the heart of every Mother of Fingers theory.
Despite being broken and abandoned, she kept waiting for another message to come.
Metyr was broken, and abandoned. Even so, she kept waiting for the Greater Will’s next message.
Who abandoned her is not clearly written. But since what she waited for was a message from the Greater Will, the natural reading is that messages from the Greater Will no longer arrived.
In the base game, the Two Fingers are said to have “stopped”. The Greater Will’s words were no longer getting through properly. One reason may lie here. The mother of the Two Fingers was broken, and could no longer receive the signs. Or the Greater Will was no longer sending them.
A weapon made from her head-finger, too, shows a vacant gaze:
The head of Metyr, the finger-mother, wielded as a weapon without modification. From within the center of the fingerprint that wrinkles the creature’s foremost protrusion, a tiny wart-like eye gazes vacantly into the beyond.
—— Gazing Finger
A tiny wart-like eye gazes vacantly into the beyond. The mother, waiting for signs that never came, gazing endlessly into the beyond.
For us, Metyr carries quite a lot of weight in Elden Ring’s world. The Lands Between was supposed to be a world watched over by the Golden Order and the Greater Will. But the mother who linked that will to the world had long since been broken and abandoned. The Greater Will may not have been looking at the Lands Between for a very long time.
What about the Erdtree seed?
Ring the other bells in the finger ruins, and you get a talisman modelled on an Erdtree seed:
A crimson-colored talisman patterned after an Erdtree seed. Boosts HP restoration from the Flask of Crimson Tears. The Erdtree was once perfect and eternal, and thus was it believed that Erdtree seeds could not exist.
—— Crimson Seed Talisman
The Erdtree was once perfect and eternal, and thus was it believed that Erdtree seeds could not exist.
Something perfect and eternal needs no next generation. So it was believed there were no seeds. And something modelled on that seed, which “could not exist”, is found in the Mother of Fingers’ ruins. It hints that the Mother of Fingers and the beginnings of the Erdtree were linked somewhere. More on the Erdtree and Marika in Who Is Queen Marika?
What was Count Ymir trying to do?
Above the ruins where Metyr lies stands a great cathedral. In it is Count Ymir, High Priest.

Count Ymir’s hat says:
The hat of Count Ymir, High Priest. The circular design at the top represents the Greater Will and its lightless abyss, imparting increased intelligence and arcane to the wearer. Though Count Ymir instructed Rellana in the sorcerous arts, he abandoned his allegiance to the moon. “It was merely the closest of the celestial bodies. Nothing more.”
—— High Priest Hat
Though Count Ymir instructed Rellana in the sorcerous arts, he abandoned his allegiance to the moon.
Count Ymir was once a sorcery teacher, who taught Rellana, the Twin Moon Knight who wields moon sorcery. But he cast off his allegiance to the moon and came to gaze into the Greater Will’s “lightless abyss”. And he came to hold a certain wish:
Robe of Count Ymir, High Priest. The front is open, exposing the squirming fingers beneath. This robe is the image of his fervent desire having broken free, laying bare his greatest wish, and wearing it enhances finger sorceries. “I will be the true mother. My fingers will grant us redemption!”
—— Finger Robe
“I will be the true mother. My fingers will grant us redemption!”
Count Ymir meant to take the broken Metyr’s place and become the “Mother of Fingers” himself. To grow fingers in his own body, and become the one who receives the Greater Will’s signs. Then the world could be guided again.
But the description of his staff is cold:
Staff of Count Ymir, who made himself a Mother of Fingers. Carried for want of tail-fingers of his own. Enhances finger sorceries. The crystal ball, though representative of a microcosm, would not receive any sign.
—— Maternal Staff
The crystal ball, though representative of a microcosm, would not receive any sign.
However closely Count Ymir imitated the mother, no sign came. And one of his sorceries says:
A finger sorcery of Count Ymir, High Priest. One of the secret hallowed rites. Conjures an image of a microcosm at a foe’s feet that pulses with a single wave before disappearing in a burst. Charging enhances potency. The broken and discarded are fully willing to cling to fleeting simulacra, earning them some modicum of sympathy.
—— Fleeting Microcosm
The broken and discarded are fully willing to cling to fleeting simulacra.
“The broken and discarded”, we think, means both Metyr and Count Ymir himself. The mother, broken and abandoned, kept waiting for the signs. Count Ymir, knowing they would not come, clung to an imitation of the mother. Both were waiting for a Greater Will that no longer answered.
Who were the people trying to become fingers?
Around Count Ymir were others who, like him, were trying to become “fingers”:
Bolus engraved with whorl-like lines. Craftable item. Boosts mind, intelligence, faith, and arcane at the cost of gradual HP loss. A secret medicine of those who attempt to turn their human bodies into fingers. Ingesting causes something to wriggle within.
—— Fingerprint Nostrum
A secret medicine of those who attempt to turn their human bodies into fingers. People who gave up being human and tried to become fingers, to draw closer to the Greater Will. In the Realm of Shadow, outside the Golden Order, there were those who tried to touch its source directly.
What the Japanese text says
This site reads the game in the original Japanese. The Japanese is harsher about those who are left waiting.
- “Earning them some modicum of sympathy.” The Fleeting Microcosm’s Japanese is 「壊れ、棄てられた者は/それと知ってなお、儚い似姿に縋る/なんと哀れなことだろうか」: the broken and abandoned, even knowing it, cling to fleeting likenesses. How pitiful. The Japanese adds それと知ってなお, even knowing it, and ends in an open cry of pity, not a measured “some modicum of sympathy”.
- “Signs” and “message”. The Japanese word is 波動, waves or vibrations: 「母は、大いなる意志の波動を受信していた」, the mother was receiving the Greater Will’s waves. It sounds more like a signal on a frequency than a message.
- “Count Ymir, who made himself a Mother of Fingers.” 「自らを指の母に擬した、ユミル卿の杖」: the staff of Count Ymir, who likened himself to the Mother of Fingers. 擬した means imitated or posed as. In Japanese he does not become a mother; he imitates one.
- “My fingers will grant us redemption!” 「私の指が、世界を救いへと導くのです」: my fingers will guide the world to salvation. 導く, to guide, is the same word as 祝福の導き, “the guidance of grace”. Count Ymir wanted to become the source of guidance himself.
What we still do not know
When and why Metyr was broken, and who abandoned her, is not written.
Whether the Greater Will truly withdrew from the Lands Between is not clear either. Perhaps Metyr only lost the ability to receive, and the Greater Will was still sending something.
And how does Metyr, who fell as the “first shooting star”, connect to the beginning of the Golden Order? Why an Erdtree seed lies in the finger ruins is never shown either.