Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / Events
What Really Happened on the Night of the Black Knives? Was Ranni Alone, or Did Marika Conspire With Her?
It was Ranni who made the blades from the Rune of Death. She admits it herself. But we do not think she could have done it alone. It was Marika who betrayed Maliketh, and the assassins were Numen close to Marika. The most natural reading is that Marika and Ranni joined hands, each for her own purpose. Why Godwyn was the target is still not clear.
What was the Night of the Black Knives?
It is the event told again and again as the start of the story.
Someone stole a fragment of the Rune of Death from Maliketh. Then, one freezing night, assassins in black killed Godwyn the Golden, Marika’s son. It was the first time a demigod had ever died.
After this, Marika shattered the Elden Ring. The demigods began fighting over its shards in “the Shattering”, and the Lands Between fell to pieces. The ruined world you walk through traces back to this one night.
Wasn’t it simply Ranni?
Half yes.
Follow Ranni’s quest, and she admits it outright:
I stole a fragment of the Rune of Death, and used it to forge the godslaying black knives through fearsome rite. I did it all.
—— Ranni
Since she says it so plainly, we think it is safe to treat Ranni as being at the centre of the event. More on her in What Was Ranni’s Goal?
But read closely, something catches. What Ranni admits is that she stole it and made the blades. How she commanded the assassins, why it was Godwyn: she says nothing of that.
One more thing. The Rune of Death was sealed by a mighty warden, Maliketh. Could a young princess really steal it from him on her own? That was the biggest question.
Was Marika an accomplice?
The answer to that question comes from Maliketh’s side.
The remembrance you receive for defeating Maliketh reads:
Maliketh was a shadowbound beast given to his Empyrean. Marika’s sole need of her shadow was a vessel to lock away Destined Death. Even then, she betrayed him.
“Destined Death” is the Rune of Death. Marika gave Maliketh the seal to keep, and then betrayed him. What she betrayed, and how, is not written. But remembering that the sealed thing was stolen, you want to connect the two.
For the very one who entrusted him with the seal, making an opening would be easy. The only one Maliketh would let his guard down for was surely his mistress, Marika. More on him in Who Is Maliketh?
Who the assassins were matters too. The Black Knife armor says:
The assassins that carried out the deeds of the Night of the Black Knives were all women, and rumored to be Numen who had close ties with Marika herself.
So Marika’s own kin went to kill Marika’s son.
Rykard’s belongings hold another clue:
A slab of rock engraved with traces of the Rune of Death. Can deflect the power of the Black Blade. On the night of the dire plot, Ranni rewarded Praetor Rykard with these traces. Should the coming trespass one day transpire, they would serve as a last-resort foil, allowing Rykard to challenge Maliketh the Black Blade, the black beast of Destined Death.
Rykard did something on the Night of the Black Knives, and was “rewarded” for it. And what he was given was a trump card against Maliketh.
So Ranni had planned from the start for Maliketh coming after them. And she had a helper, Rykard. From this too, we think it is fair to say it was not an event she caused alone.
Put together, it reads like this. Marika arranged for the Rune of Death to be taken out. Ranni received it and made it into blades. The assassins came from a people close to Marika.
For us, this conspiracy theory fits best. It does not contradict Ranni’s confession. Ranni says “I did it all”, but in Japanese she does not say she did it alone. See below.
So why would Marika have her son killed?
This is the hardest part.
It is hard to imagine a mother helping to assassinate her own son. So there is a view that “Marika’s real target was never Godwyn.”
Inside Marika is Radagon. The two share one body, yet think entirely differently. Perhaps what Marika really wanted to kill was Radagon, or the Greater Will behind him. Somewhere the plan went wrong, and Godwyn died. Read that way, it also explains why Marika then shattered the Elden Ring as if she had lost her mind. More on Radagon in Who Is Radagon?
For Ranni too, Godwyn was surely not the real target. Ranni’s goal was to kill her own body and escape the Two Fingers’ control.
The proof is the “Cursemark of Death”:
This cursemark was carved at the moment of Death of the first demigod, and should have taken the shape of a circle. However, two demigods perished at the same time, breaking the cursemark into two half-wheels. Ranni was the first of the demigods whose flesh perished, while the Prince of Death perished in soul alone.
One was Godwyn. The other was Ranni herself, who cast off her body. For Ranni, the Night of the Black Knives was also the night she killed herself. More on Godwyn in Who Is Godwyn the Golden?
What about Miquella or Radagon as the mastermind?
Both theories are persistent.
The Miquella conspiracy theory says that Miquella, who wanted a body to serve as a lord’s vessel, and Ranni, who wanted to cast off her body, had interests that matched. It is an interesting idea. But the DLC showed that what Miquella truly wanted was to take Radahn as his consort. That makes a motive to target Godwyn’s body much weaker, we think.
On the other hand, since the DLC, more people have come to see Miquella as having moved everything from behind the scenes. The DLC made it clear that Miquella had the power of “charm”, which draws people’s hearts to him. Ranni and Marika may have been moved without knowing it, so the reading goes. But we found no text, DLC included, that says Miquella was involved in the Night of the Black Knives. For now, we think it stays in the realm of imagination. More in What Was Miquella’s Goal?
There is also the theory that Radagon or the Two Fingers were behind it all: Ranni and the others thought they were carrying out their plan, but were in fact being manipulated. It is not impossible, but we see no text in the game that points to it directly. For now, it feels like one more step of inference than the other theories.
What the Japanese text says
This site reads the game in the original Japanese. Two lines read differently there, and both matter for this case.
- “I did it all.” Ranni’s Japanese is 「すべて私が、やったことだ」: all of it is something I did. It claims responsibility for every part, but it is not “I alone did it”. The English “I did it all” can sound like she did everything by herself. The Japanese leaves room for others who helped.
- “Even then, she betrayed him.” The Japanese is 「マリカは影従に、運命の死の封印たるを望み/後にそれを裏切ったのだ」: Marika wished her shadow to be the seal of Destined Death, and later betrayed that. In Japanese, what she betrayed can be read as the seal itself, not only Maliketh. Betraying the seal is exactly what letting the Rune of Death be stolen would be. The English “Marika’s sole need of her shadow was a vessel” also adds a coldness the Japanese does not have.
- “Ranni rewarded Praetor Rykard.” The Blasphemous Claw’s Japanese is 「ラニから謝礼として片鱗を貰い受けた」: received the fragment from Ranni as thanks. 謝礼 is payment for a service rendered, which makes it clear Rykard had done something for her that night.
What we still do not know
Let us be honest.
Why Godwyn was targeted has no decisive answer in any theory. That Marika’s real target was Radagon is inference too; no text says so anywhere.
How Rykard was involved is clear only in part.
But lay Ranni’s confession, Maliketh’s remembrance and the assassins’ identity side by side, and at least one thing comes into view: it was not Ranni’s crime alone. The Night of the Black Knives, we think, was less one mastermind’s plan than an event that several people with different goals all rode on the same night.