Kousatsu Note / Elden Ring / People

Who Is Pidia in Elden Ring? Why the Keeper of the "Ghastly Dolls" Cried "I Loved You with All I Have" as He Died

Updated: 2026-10-25
On a dark stone floor, a thin old man with a white beard falls back, mouth open as if in fear
Pidia, Carian Servant Game image ©Bandai Namco Entertainment Inc. / ©2022 FromSoftware, Inc. (image source: ELDEN RING Wiki / eldenring.wiki.gg)
The short answer Strong inference

Pidia is a servant of the Carian royal family, charged with tending the dolls in a storeroom at the back of Caria Manor. When you first meet him, Pidia calls them "ghastly dolls", calls himself "poor ill-starred Pidia", and asks for runes. But when the storeroom is attacked by the doll soldiers, Pidia cries out to them, "You're my puppets! I loved you with all I have!" The dolls he called ghastly, Pidia truly loved. And what he loved were his own "puppets". In the storeroom were left the puppets of Nepheli, the warrior of the Roundtable Hold, and of the hunter Dolores, once a friend of Gideon. Pidia's story, we think, is the story of another lover of puppets, hidden behind the sorcery preceptor Seluvis and his secret pastime. More on his relationship with Seluvis in [Who Is Seluvis?](/en/eldenring/seluvis/)

Who is Pidia?

North of Liurnia of the Lakes is Caria Manor. Climb down across its rooftops, and in a storeroom hidden from view is a thin old man. When he notices the player, he is badly startled:

O-oh! Y-you! I, er, sorry, your worship… I-I apologize for any offence given. I am Pidia, Servant to the Carian royal family. I am charged with maintaining these g-ghastly dolls.

—— Pidia, Carian Servant

I am charged with maintaining these ghastly dolls.

In Pidia’s storeroom stand rows of doll-like soldiers. Pidia was their keeper.

What is “poor ill-starred Pidia”?

Pidia sells you the storeroom’s goods:

Ahh, your worship, allow me to be of use. Other than the puppets, there are some very fine things up here in this storeroom. Why not pick something out, before you go? But please, can you offer poor ill-starred Pidia… A little something by way of compensation?

—— Pidia, Carian Servant

Poor ill-starred Pidia.

He calls himself “poor” and “ill-starred”, and humbly asks for payment. A servile, somewhat comic servant. And the storeroom does hold rare goods, starting with celestial dew, which undoes broken bonds. More on celestial dew in Who Is Miriel?

Once you have bought everything, Pidia says:

Ah, I’m sorry your worship, but poor Pidia has given all he has. I can’t be of further use to you. Please, forgive me.

—— Pidia, Carian Servant

What were the dolls in the storeroom?

The “dolls” Pidia kept were “puppets” made by the sorcery preceptor Seluvis.

Puppets are people whose minds have been taken by a potion. Seluvis turned those he favoured into puppets and collected them. The descriptions of the puppets left in Pidia’s storeroom say so:

One of Seluvis’ favorite puppets. Use to summon the spirit of Dolores the Sleeping Arrow. Spirit of a handsome archer who dressed in the style of a man. Called the Silent Hunter by some, she fires St. Trina’s arrows from her shortbow. Dolores once belonged to the Roundtable Hold, where she was both a critic and a friend of Gideon the All-Knowing. It was because of her that he and Seluvis went their separate ways.

—— Dolores the Sleeping Arrow Puppet

Dolores once belonged to the Roundtable Hold, where she was both a critic and a friend of Gideon the All-Knowing.

The hunter Dolores, a friend of Gideon, master of the Roundtable Hold, and one who could criticise him. That Dolores had been made into Seluvis’s puppet. And that is why Gideon and Seluvis went their separate ways. More on Gideon in Who Is Gideon Ofnir?

The other is Nepheli’s puppet, left if the player gave Seluvis’s potion to Nepheli:

One of Seluvis’s favorite puppets. Use to summon the spirit of Nepheli Loux. Puppet of a warrior who was betrayed by her pure heart. Wields a Stormhawk Axe in both hands and uses the Thunderstorm skill. A diamond in the rough, deserving of special care lest its potential be squandered. Nepheli Loux truly was a warrior.

—— Nepheli Loux Puppet

A diamond in the rough, deserving of special care. The warped affection of someone who collects puppets. More on Nepheli in Who Is Nepheli Loux?

What did Pidia cry as he died?

This is the heart of every Pidia theory.

After progressing Ranni’s quest, approach Pidia’s storeroom and you hear screams:

Argh! Aargh! S-stop, please, stop! Y-you’re my puppets! I loved you with all I have! How could you forget… such bliss? Ouch! That hurts! Please, I beg you, cease this cruelty!

—— Pidia, Carian Servant

In a dim stone hall, armored soldiers surround and look down on a fallen old man
Pidia, fallen and surrounded by the puppet soldiersGame image ©Bandai Namco Entertainment Inc. / ©2022 FromSoftware, Inc. (image source: ELDEN RING Wiki / eldenring.wiki.gg)

You’re my puppets! I loved you with all I have! How could you forget… such bliss?

Pidia, who called them “ghastly dolls” in front of the player, calls them “my puppets” as he dies, and cries that he loved them with all he had.

Pidia was not just a servant “charged with maintaining” the dolls. He loved them as his own puppets. “Ghastly” was a word put on for the player’s benefit.

And what Pidia gave the puppets was, in his own words, “bliss”. To have your mind taken, and be cherished. Pidia truly believed that was a puppet’s happiness. When the puppets turned their blades on him, he lamented: had they forgotten that bliss?

Are Pidia and Seluvis the same person?

Around the time Pidia dies, the sorcery preceptor Seluvis, in his tower, is also found dead, in the same state as a puppet. And when you first meet Pidia, he starts to address the player plainly, “Y-you!”, then corrects himself to “your worship”. In Japanese, the way he first calls the player is exactly how Seluvis addresses them (see below).

From this comes the theory that Seluvis was a puppet controlled by Pidia, and that the real puppeteer was Pidia. This site, too, finds that reading convincing. The detailed evidence is in Who Is Seluvis?

If so, “poor ill-starred Pidia” was the true master of the puppets, who put forward a fine puppet in the form of the preceptor Seluvis while hiding in the storeroom as a servant. The servile servant himself may have been Pidia’s mask.

What the Japanese text says

This site reads the game in the original Japanese. Two details matter more there.

  • “Y-you! I, er, sorry, your worship.” The Japanese is 「き、きみ…、いえ、貴方様は…」: y-you (kimi)… no, your worship… きみ (君) is a casual “you”, and it is how Seluvis addresses the player throughout. In Japanese, Pidia slipping into Seluvis’s 君 before correcting himself is one of the main clues for the theory that they are the same person. The English “you” cannot carry that.
  • “A diamond in the rough, deserving of special care lest its potential be squandered.” The Nepheli puppet’s Japanese is 「原石は、原石であるが故に傷つきやすく/だからこそ、特に愛でる価値もあろう」: an uncut gem, being uncut, is easily damaged, and for that very reason is especially worth cherishing. In Japanese, the puppet is worth cherishing because it is fragile and easily hurt. The English turns it into protecting potential, and the twisted taste is softer.
  • “Puppet of a warrior who was betrayed by her pure heart.” 「純粋で、故に心折れた戦士の傀儡」: the puppet of a warrior who was pure, and therefore broke.
  • “I loved you with all I have!” 「お前たちは私の傀儡、あんなに愛してあげたじゃないか」: you are my puppets. Didn’t I love you so much? 愛してあげた is love given as a favour, from above. It sounds like a master speaking to things he owns.

What we still do not know

How long Pidia had served the Carian royal family is not told.

Whether the puppets that attacked Pidia turned on their master of their own will, or were ordered to by someone, we do not know either.

And did Pidia really control Seluvis? The text never says so directly.